[ { "comment_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg", "comment_text": "Buy the Book:\nhttps://usefulcharts.com/collections/books/products/timeline-of-world-history-book", "likes": "34 likes", "replies": "32 replies", "username": "@UsefulCharts", "username_md5": "a8e1a413c0185bb94ef44fe26398ce83", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@UsefulCharts", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Is the book no longer available on your site?", "reply_like": "2 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9lMVsMD_27j", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC-r9Kx5hMsk9JiyULljIyeA", "user_id_md5": "da19ce128814a39f26ac3733a5dabfe9", "user_name": "@ItsStanleyC", "user_name_md5": "d5c49ea74b2b152c2b2bf61623f1d45a" }, { "reply_text": "This link takes me to a page “404 page not found The page does not exist”. Where can I buy the book?", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9lgBE9CbPtE", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCPBpP0XkXjQ9LxQbKwiwpUg", "user_id_md5": "7c94a12b8846e39c4b9826d62a9b8e8f", "user_name": "@adrianahubert6964", "user_name_md5": "2471ef611f9f2a10cbb6ad0e06c7ca10" }, { "reply_text": "Do you have pdfs or smthing?", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9g2I2i2K1MK", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UCyEw0ZZmRR4k3iJdZaJbcWg", "user_id_md5": "e1c847478ede00c31885933cc6f12281", "user_name": "@Destroyer120296", "user_name_md5": "6746a7dc72ae29a11b3231abb547597b" }, { "reply_text": "No PDFs due to copyright issues.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9g2Jxb5QvYw", "reply_rank": 4, "user_id": "UC7o-UFkoAPCoKxpKOfrs4zQ", "user_id_md5": "a366c1459fcd0648a338ac5cf5fdee9a", "user_name": "@UsefulCharts", "user_name_md5": "a8e1a413c0185bb94ef44fe26398ce83" }, { "reply_text": "Unfortunately, I can't buy your products because I do not have a credit card as it is not as popular in Europe as in the US. Maybe you can add PayPal as an option in the near future. We usually have only debit cards.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9g4MpgQ1w4v", "reply_rank": 5, "user_id": "UCB5EeSwmMoLP_9rTd9oenpg", "user_id_md5": "26db160b96431c51b973ce8808bc2d51", "user_name": "@DJKLProductions", "user_name_md5": "b513cd5e062ed998882e1ee02da259d0" }, { "reply_text": "When I put in a New Zealand address, the website says it can’t post there", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9g63bWwTAMW", "reply_rank": 6, "user_id": "UC3E9trjbR3srDux0e_5N63Q", "user_id_md5": "0a3400bc193f6e12e394644574c08ac3", "user_name": "@sheppardtribe", "user_name_md5": "18703bf8f8610efc3051d849adc80cee" }, { "reply_text": "I really want this book but with post and other taxes it´s price is for me 90€ and that´s a really expensive for me😞", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9g7doxgRrlH", "reply_rank": 7, "user_id": "UChFvMNTxuXvtdoVDfEpxjJw", "user_id_md5": "70d9c42ec629a275207e2766af7ff52b", "user_name": "@luboss822", "user_name_md5": "6e8e4de0a6d8ab82dbd41acf69c98f11" }, { "reply_text": "Thank you SO much for your videos. This overview was incredibly helpful in discovering family history. If schools taught like this when I was younger, history would have been much more interesting and enjoyable. \n I can't wait to get your book and a chart (or maybe more than one) I'm interested in! \n Thank you again! It's nice to have someone put so much into beautiful charts and your book sounds very interesting. I'm looking Foreward to getting them when I put an order together! ❤", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9gBgefE6Z-e", "reply_rank": 8, "user_id": "UCsaf-Q3WmxbmLqBawDF133g", "user_id_md5": "d090f82bd51a1a97a5db234c67986c55", "user_name": "@CarolReidCA", "user_name_md5": "31f8174cd8f5b6bb25764531bd6390dd" }, { "reply_text": "can this be shipped to indonesia?", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9gCN4OCkEVs", "reply_rank": 9, "user_id": "UCIr1FU37b455iwHkymimsPQ", "user_id_md5": "da7cbb771e289c8f3bcaec44b6e4e43d", "user_name": "@okyoky405", "user_name_md5": "5884855351996a4db6ae3183e48815d1" }, { "reply_text": "The book is currently sold out. Do you know when you will have them back in stock?", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9gTJ2hJTfe-", "reply_rank": 10, "user_id": "UCzskCL9_iIIg3lNFxEX_c4Q", "user_id_md5": "f38266bb3f91069274c323317557e41b", "user_name": "@Sandi_Hurd", "user_name_md5": "5bbf40e7ebf492781b131d32697c268e" }, { "reply_text": "Not available in PDF?", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9jZM1oMhaN_", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC18k4rUPMJwCY3BLxC5QvGQ", "user_id_md5": "3c9deb8e1aba76639626daae70a6fc74", "user_name": "@azhivago2296", "user_name_md5": "5fe2b0affc62ce73e2bdbafaec530167" }, { "reply_text": "I need collections book this all in one.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9k8p6H7arqw", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCqCOJy937Am8cZ_jdLr_FXw", "user_id_md5": "336bba12971d603ef6120fa8f9235df1", "user_name": "@milanrai4432", "user_name_md5": "665c332898880ed14a518c755ff5832c" }, { "reply_text": "Good day.. I would like to purchase the book the link in the description is now working either is the one pinned in the comments section. One question I would like to ask, is the history timeline poster with this book the same size as the posters you have for sale (24\" x 36\")?", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9o0G_oMDbPi", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UCG8Lk5XSAtP2pwBNhLeAoWg", "user_id_md5": "ba672aae11e6b73aaff739b59775046d", "user_name": "@mouricedixon6181", "user_name_md5": "38e5e17f06a3fb95969105e0db1f19ab" }, { "reply_text": "You have to stop hypothetically connecting the Atlantis myth to the Thera eruption. There is no concrete evidence for the myth prior to Plato, which leaves us pretty safe to assume that it was his own creation to be used in his dialogue. Sure, there may have been something up in the air from various legends, but you can't connect Atlantis to a single historical event because it's just not scientific.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9oNGswrSTZ9", "reply_rank": 4, "user_id": "UCkDJf3vanpI8a7X93Pqv1mA", "user_id_md5": "8dbd96c381eca99a31be034d15ab50a7", "user_name": "@joshygoldiem_j2799", "user_name_md5": "ab79058fab7cdd2296d45d29c63a7465" }, { "reply_text": "​ @joshygoldiem_j2799  Don't confuse historical standards with scientific ones. History and science are very different fields. Most professional historians have no problem stating that the Thera eruption MAY HAVE inspired the Atlantis myth (key phrase being \"may have\").", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9oOMBsAu3Rr", "reply_rank": 5, "user_id": "UC7o-UFkoAPCoKxpKOfrs4zQ", "user_id_md5": "a366c1459fcd0648a338ac5cf5fdee9a", "user_name": "@UsefulCharts", "user_name_md5": "a8e1a413c0185bb94ef44fe26398ce83" }, { "reply_text": "Think I should've put it this way instead. It is in fact true that historians have drawn connections between Atlantis and the Thera eruption, but that calls for an unbroken chain of storytelling down to Plato spanning approx 1,300 years. My problem is that you've used the following wording, \"which also birthed the well-known myth of Atlantis.\" In other words, you've described it as a fact instead of a theory. In the absence of evidence for pre-Platonic versions of the narrative, the idea remains entirely theoretical. This is what I was trying to imply when I used the word \"scientific,\" as in evidence-based. And unfortunately, we have collected a minimal amount of evidence in this regard. When combined with the lengthy timespan - not to mention the Bronze Age Collapse - the theory calls for, I find the idea of Atlantis being based on that single event quite difficult to buy. So I still argue that Plato made it up from scratch.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9vNe6p2nmxv", "reply_rank": 6, "user_id": "UCkDJf3vanpI8a7X93Pqv1mA", "user_id_md5": "8dbd96c381eca99a31be034d15ab50a7", "user_name": "@joshygoldiem_j2799", "user_name_md5": "ab79058fab7cdd2296d45d29c63a7465" }, { "reply_text": "Slavs didn't arrive from Asia. That is Russo-German propaganda. Slavs were present in area East of Vistula as far as 1'th century, with Romans refering to them as Veneti (later Germans called them Wends). South Slavs arrived on Balkans in 6'th century from North, what happen after nomadic tribes ravaged area earlier. But Serbs specifically come from East Germany (where they relatives still live) and Croat South-East Poland. Something what was confirmed by both Byzantines, who recognised them as Veneti and they own sources. Some of mentioned Asiatic tribes later adopt Slavic culture (Bulgar and Muscovy). What lead to confusion about origin of Slavs. Also Roman Galia never did actually fall.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyLAMgQGkjTBAn", "reply_rank": 7, "user_id": "UCuJh7hwIGSPQk_UWANj0f-A", "user_id_md5": "386c9f8b6a5d01174ca44fa100e2baba", "user_name": "@TheRezro", "user_name_md5": "0c8bdc27d49f871926389739f0cf91c6" }, { "reply_text": "Few other corrections. Moravia was originally founded by Frankish Merchants (Germans), what later was the reason why region was annexed by them. But Moravia also did have connection to Poland, as Cracow was originally a Moravian city, what was center of trade with Vistulan tribes up to North aka the Polans. After Moravia fall, contact was lost, until missionaries reestablished it again later. Here it would be also worth to add conection between Prussia and Poland. As after fall of Tatuownic Order, Poland regain control over rebelling province. Until it was stolen again by Germans.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyLAMgShyXdotO", "reply_rank": 8, "user_id": "UCuJh7hwIGSPQk_UWANj0f-A", "user_id_md5": "386c9f8b6a5d01174ca44fa100e2baba", "user_name": "@TheRezro", "user_name_md5": "0c8bdc27d49f871926389739f0cf91c6" }, { "reply_text": " @UsefulCharts  to be fair you haven't clarified that in the video. Additionally, if there was an Atlantis myth floating around before Plato, it would've likely been influenced by various legends and stories rather than just one. When I said scientific I did mean in the sense of historical research, by the way.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxpKy-vbSFBSWM1Ck54AaABAg.9g2DCsgSsyL9oOhe1VJsvZ", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCkDJf3vanpI8a7X93Pqv1mA", "user_id_md5": "8dbd96c381eca99a31be034d15ab50a7", "user_name": "@joshygoldiem_j2799", "user_name_md5": "ab79058fab7cdd2296d45d29c63a7465" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC7o-UFkoAPCoKxpKOfrs4zQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzwFy3AAl174jS-oHx4AaABAg", "comment_text": "As a historian and person from Eastern Europe this chart is outrageously bad. You should've really called it chart of Western Europe history and just skipped every country east of Germany and Italy all together.\nI understand that you cannot fit it all in one chart,but then just don't try it.\nSlavs coming from Asia in 6 century? Ignoring completely Baltic states, Romania,Albania and many more countries...\nAt the end of this video, everything east of Germany is just Russia, Greece and \"Balkans\"??", "likes": "9 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@omtomic", "username_md5": "b288ebc76207187f8543f6d55e596efe", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@omtomic", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCMCim5Qig_IGacOOijvdO4g", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxP-PxP55UVN-V3yQh4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Great!\nHowever, the Slavs didn't arrive from Asia. They formed in the Danube or the Dnieper region that are wholly in Europe.", "likes": "6 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@BiglerSakura", "username_md5": "65eca3a9403c15f4809e61170dd335eb", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@BiglerSakura", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCwN-W06nqrnwFuPN1qvdXJg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwTwLxFtp94C02k8kJ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I just got my book a few days ago and I’m so very excited to share this with my friends on camping trips and hopefully with my own children some day! It’s been a pleasure looking at the pictures and reading over the subjects. Made me feel like a kid again", "likes": "39 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@ianfitzpatrick2230", "username_md5": "2a273e0073b5cd0b05e1a2b01233a3ea", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@ianfitzpatrick2230", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCPt-BKqaCoG-TX1zyTW5PMA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxkwzwSAXe5PRzw7NV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Portugal as one of the oldest countries does not make it to the end.", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@usmcforever7630", "username_md5": "5c2d65e77dc3f8026c4ae008ed7170ff", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@usmcforever7630", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCvwXjOg_jaMcWa0G6PgR3TQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwTt-SsaFnLv6jN7LB4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Matt is a great teacher, which is a gift. Another excellent overview of a huge timeline and wealth of information.", "likes": "26 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@debraturner4559", "username_md5": "a1dd5c56ca5594ce72358c508f3afb59", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@debraturner4559", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCf6OR0Uqu-F41WNxafeDaMw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxRaiSJxJQMA2HAjFF4AaABAg", "comment_text": "What an amazing chart and book.", "likes": "4 likes", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@lostfan5054", "username_md5": "b93c42c6fb9f7db96857e0fdcd046197", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@lostfan5054", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "I'm going to order the book and at least 1 chart, if not more! It's wonderful to have such a knowledgeable person put together a book and charts to bring history alive, and to be able to see events from all over regions and the world for a better handle of what went on and where, worldwide. \n I may get my granddaughter a copy as well. It would be great if schools picked up the charts and the book as well. This brings history alive and makes it far more interesting!", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxRaiSJxJQMA2HAjFF4AaABAg.9g4gDAVQqPY9gBh_o2XGA4", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCsaf-Q3WmxbmLqBawDF133g", "user_id_md5": "d090f82bd51a1a97a5db234c67986c55", "user_name": "@CarolReidCA", "user_name_md5": "31f8174cd8f5b6bb25764531bd6390dd" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC2qW4FmzFR-jgwDDdbjQwPg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwUo3vq95VBjAtaClN4AaABAg", "comment_text": "6:53 Slavs and Avars from Asia?! Since when?", "likes": "7 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@Nakaska", "username_md5": "7e5ec56fa3d36f4a744544ebfc666760", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Nakaska", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC-ewW4SODCJZRHuoe-8RGnA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzUNQYtuo4fynvDrEV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Good job with this video! I want to point out that the Slavs did not arrive from Asia, but from Eastern Europe (around modern-day Ukraine and Belarus). Also, The First Bulgarian empire lasted for much longer than you show in the chart. It is founded in 681 by refugees from the former Old Great Bulgaria and was annexed in 1018 by East Rome. There is also the second Bulgarian empire which lasted from 1185 - 1396/1422.", "likes": "18 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@Marti_Monev", "username_md5": "45c2e8bca00fdc91812612406f13d3ef", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Marti_Monev", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCk-cVtX-b6VOnSwzImp0r0A", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugxsy0ll6dw2kKarAN14AaABAg", "comment_text": "Love that you included Florence Nightingale on the chart even if she didn't make it into the video. Quite the influencial figure on science, or more specificially statistics and modern medicine.", "likes": "18 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@N1ghthavvk", "username_md5": "54cc87665f13764d693cb43fda5a5829", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@N1ghthavvk", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCCfA5T5D9gTmZBWRftPJETw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugwt4KgOzk6vT68wyuV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I just want to say that I love your work. Extraordinary, dude! Please continue :) (and I have everything [book and posters] from your site up to the beginning of this year) I love them all! Thanks again for the great contribution to the world, that is your work!", "likes": "14 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@slimchance1812", "username_md5": "6bf8d3fc32257ba20a756e8b6f6ee34d", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@slimchance1812", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCilKgQMrRpuuB3BtMsfSzBw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugx_HozaaaNcZMzUwRJ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Can you do a family tree for the Queen's corgis?", "likes": "4 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@Steedie", "username_md5": "77783a76923afefc2a17284dddbe4efb", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Steedie", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC-xbsq7ZTuzKfKF5ylmSqMw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugz0xVQcqFJv8R4CMHl4AaABAg", "comment_text": "There is something weird going on, that makes it looks like Austria hungary survived until WWII", "likes": "3 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@tirex3673", "username_md5": "5f0af04cdc9367157f0afd0c1b24f341", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@tirex3673", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCVBg1sqpDFIjucLYgz2IOcw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugz09vGbC6JsYi3UTx54AaABAg", "comment_text": "Your book sounds like a treasure for history lovers!", "likes": "5 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@ruthanneseven", "username_md5": "c248b04f9553e3fcfeadbd890ce701ca", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@ruthanneseven", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCZ10Uq9I25OomSXVkH0EBnw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugy1uqqbn78haRfmDCl4AaABAg", "comment_text": "One small change I'd make for the Dutch Republic is to begin their existence around 1588, because the reason the Netherlands so quickly dominated the spice trade was because Portugal and Spain were united. This made it so the Dutch weren't only fighting the Spanish, but also the Portuguese, thus giving the Dutch a reason to take over the trading posts and colonies established by the Portuguese.", "likes": "7 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@DutchSimmer1", "username_md5": "585c84e0d22d0d599bc42494981fb7a4", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@DutchSimmer1", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCpZCTa1SgOP5o9FgN33z1yQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwY4x8wAuY6i-O_Qo54AaABAg", "comment_text": "Nice, as a Pole for me it will be nice to include in this poster that WE ARE BACK :D", "likes": "15 likes", "replies": "4 replies", "username": "@DGronki", "username_md5": "e78253898a3b86be65d92c63d56b0a63", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@DGronki", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "He also erased Portugal... lol", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgwY4x8wAuY6i-O_Qo54AaABAg.9g2J-4A-zcJ9hAV4CE2ogh", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCtgeQ48eryJqW15K19plbDQ", "user_id_md5": "dfcf6d7c54a4962eba3bcdd2fa5b3bbf", "user_name": "@joaomramalho1", "user_name_md5": "cf4aa927615e1141cfa4c6385a60f730" }, { "reply_text": "Who is back?", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgwY4x8wAuY6i-O_Qo54AaABAg.9g2J-4A-zcJ9g2fI9ppoJf", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCPod-ByQuyCNeaPjGvY2Slg", "user_id_md5": "619f9cff26f4f387f2f7bed1e2e909c0", "user_name": "@charliedegiulio9951", "user_name_md5": "a7675ac04b67a42eb59e0c6d534f739b" }, { "reply_text": " @charliedegiulio9951  Poland, because time line ends with partitioning of Poland but it was not the end.", "reply_like": "2 likes", "reply_id": "UgwY4x8wAuY6i-O_Qo54AaABAg.9g2J-4A-zcJ9g3HQNwfMnQ", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UCO4PsH3qDox1Semine3mZMg", "user_id_md5": "18181fbcbf3685d4ed803b7f1882a12e", "user_name": "@DGronki", "user_name_md5": "e78253898a3b86be65d92c63d56b0a63" }, { "reply_text": " @DGronki  They have another chart about European history. You should check that one.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgwY4x8wAuY6i-O_Qo54AaABAg.9g2J-4A-zcJ9g4KQJjZaVD", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCPod-ByQuyCNeaPjGvY2Slg", "user_id_md5": "619f9cff26f4f387f2f7bed1e2e909c0", "user_name": "@charliedegiulio9951", "user_name_md5": "a7675ac04b67a42eb59e0c6d534f739b" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCO4PsH3qDox1Semine3mZMg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyaZOt3t0UPlF0rskd4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Awesome video and chart. Just One correction though.\nLouis XVI of France was not the grandson of Louis XIV (the sun king). Louis XIV outlived his heir and HIS heir and was followed by his great-grandson Louis XV, who also outlived his heir, to be followed by his grandson Louis XVI (who was killed in the french revolution).\nSo it's a total of not three but six generations.\nAlso: thanks for including the little detail of the two separated parts of Germany. It was an \"interesting\" century for us xD", "likes": "10 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@dorderre", "username_md5": "07ffd7d5de51da638307b87473dd9ae4", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@dorderre", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCAr9tih49BNPGW6FQncwwyQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugx2F3bGXwEFbiWzK4d4AaABAg", "comment_text": "One of the best history videos I've seen. Very well structured.", "likes": "6 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@silentsoup8857", "username_md5": "67c72ebdbcd4ccd58a8116fff0228e83", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@silentsoup8857", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UChYHmI9xXck8G6IMEwEKbvg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyqaiMj-BFWI5_L4Jp4AaABAg", "comment_text": "You’ve neglected to mention the 12th Century Renaissance in Iberia.", "likes": "3 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@patriciaaturner289", "username_md5": "0c34c258b556f93127de0eab89a9ae07", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@patriciaaturner289", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCGdm9iqhC5Uo3Pb0hE_rmBQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxaTzAzXcJcC-XSajp4AaABAg", "comment_text": "*1861 for Italy, 1871 for Germany", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@marcorusso5591", "username_md5": "60699221c3a307c2459b56f82edeaa68", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@marcorusso5591", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCvgpfDEz5rY4mBKBJU7nVOQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwjLg-gXhCrKX5dci54AaABAg", "comment_text": "Very cool stuff! recover soon!", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@mariannaweener", "username_md5": "b76bf0e4c03c097b228c4cbbd76f3ba3", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@mariannaweener", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCbnJGxokdPu3-9UyjGOPIIQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugx223sXOoa6ll5PrEp4AaABAg", "comment_text": "3:57 Carthaginians, Romans, & Greece\n4:55 5th Century Athenian Golden Age\n5:29 Roman Empire\n5:56 Germanic Tribes\n6:05 \nOstrogoth = East Goth\nLombards = Germanic Rulers of Italy \nVisigoth = West Goth\n6:49 Avars, Bulgars, & Slavs\n\n7:00 The Franks\n7:23 Rome split, now centered at Byzantium. \n\n7:50 Frankish Kingdom splits into France & The Holy Roman Empire\n\n8:45 Caliphate of Cordoba\n\n9:35 👑 Kingdoms of England 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 & Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 \n\n10:25 Crusades, Iberian Religious War.\n\n11:00 Florence & Venice Artistic Golden Age. \n\n11:54 Kalmar Union\nQueen Margrete I 1410-1510 approximarely\nNorway 🇳🇴 \nDenmark 🇩🇰 \nSweden 🇸🇪 \n\n12:05 Swedish Independence 1523\n\n12:20 \nEngland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 Conquered Wales 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿 \nEngland Merged with Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 \n🇬🇧 \n\nBLACK DEATH\n12:38 Bourbon France \n13:00 Louis XIV —> Louis XV —> Napoleon\n\n13:25 Industrial Revolution.\n\n13:35 House of Hapsburg \n13:53 30 Years War\nBrandenburg —> Prussia —> Kaiser Germany —> Weimar Germany —> Nazi Germany —> Republic Germany\n\n14:20 Spanish History\n14:53 The Dutch Republic\n\n15:01 Italy Renaissance \n1871 Kingdom of Italy 👑 \n1946 Italian Republic\n\n15:55 Poland 🇵🇱 \n16:04 Russia 🇷🇺", "likes": "5 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@thattimestampguy", "username_md5": "d80a73e155655f529c9024d47eedfcba", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@thattimestampguy", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCXe_jZjinfySXXtkVwaAWrQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugxp4qmu1wi4yN-8pdV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "What an absolutely exceptional chart! Congratulations to the designers!", "likes": "13 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@Nooticus", "username_md5": "c025b4332f42752abd6a69e8bf3f2a6f", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Nooticus", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCwMRzYNw5r322ER3C_vjR5A", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugzw4poD74467ZS3EhR4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Have you considered a European distributor? With digital printing as it is it shouldn’t be too difficult to arrange. I’d love to buy some of your charts, but the shipping from the USA is ridiculously expensive. I can’t justify spending more on shipping that charts actually cost.", "likes": "15 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@ffotograffydd", "username_md5": "f5be901df5b8df2b26c0a6c60a5ce590", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@ffotograffydd", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC-l-tmvbrJmUtfQQm4T83jw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugw4q-84K-88poSCqUR4AaABAg", "comment_text": "seems like Europe is bunch of cousins getting together", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@hellohumans175", "username_md5": "d911fb8c16caf3b26db38c6caaecab4f", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@hellohumans175", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC7PZGEzfmMRJD2feQ1KV7qw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyLFJLhUPlWF-En1XZ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I LOVE THIS CHANNEL!", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@openclassusa3534", "username_md5": "94f1be9f2b3399197ce9e8289d9d516a", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@openclassusa3534", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC8T7TDDOX0g4-oOSTq5F08Q", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyE8YNemhTjoQJgxiB4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Damn loved this", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@su_chiita", "username_md5": "b2732233d07a80afb2eaf6431acaf071", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@su_chiita", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCDF_4PGVdYqM4wSEauCmc9Q", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwzeMDIjINAdj1QCWR4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I have been watching your videos for ages now and I am currently in Vancouver for a few months so I am definitely coming for a visit to the store!", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@aiolusx", "username_md5": "dd30c2c867c173b89b5a16eb74546ffd", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@aiolusx", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCfdKDhO7BIslcNnfr3E7S4w", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxSV462ANgvrS6-x-t4AaABAg", "comment_text": "So good 🔥", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@investingwithapurpose", "username_md5": "d8d33bdb0e115a14b3df64594b49000d", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@investingwithapurpose", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC0vHRn7HvGlyoFNCZBQhR9A", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugzb3WZ1CYvw8P0AarR4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Such great depiction of all important things .. quick in hand data and information ... So thankful to you for creating these", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@MomandAflatoon", "username_md5": "fc8f462de6c1922fdb3c5674cc07d871", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@MomandAflatoon", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCOU7fA_9bo3D6EAofTZxIVA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwczpIdg2TsmioQVgR4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I like the way you kept the 100 years at equal intervals (no compression of time). I do prefer the AD vs CE though.", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@stewartglass", "username_md5": "1622aed51ff07ed570d5b245f6bb494f", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@stewartglass", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Me too. \"common era\" makes no sense", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgwczpIdg2TsmioQVgR4AaABAg.A1MoJqaQP2OADBUC05reY1", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCs1EApX1SsAd1iBL473ynaA", "user_id_md5": "a448ea33d7fa3ccaaa3a91c2a9197256", "user_name": "@Mateo-et3wl", "user_name_md5": "967dc15dbfb1eaf57e1e9775361fe229" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCYOM8TzA5ylqGEXcKkaFKxw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwcQMiAHaV8A0C3dMx4AaABAg", "comment_text": "what a useful chart! I can't believe that I find this channel so late.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@datactive859", "username_md5": "1e478194e3694e8678ac91cea76cb627", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@datactive859", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC6u44QMkPDo-9q_b9tAK1kw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugw2tAlR5-fEaJ5YTPd4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I thought European history would be older", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@premprasun1516", "username_md5": "dafb650655203ea1dee3e2f1814cd753", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@premprasun1516", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC6IK5Ls8JvhYPjBGExzxIJw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzmbSBDFjUwsmf8BdV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Great work! Thanks!", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@LinguaAnglica_FP", "username_md5": "7ce02188aab73e9e602f7f8cc6d4852f", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@LinguaAnglica_FP", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCRjqnafQXPl31kOURyiYVnw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzlgqwUkAOnqzc_yCV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "So ridiculous that Portugal is erased from the chart in the 16th century. UGH!!....", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@joaomramalho1", "username_md5": "cf4aa927615e1141cfa4c6385a60f730", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@joaomramalho1", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCtgeQ48eryJqW15K19plbDQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwBgMqMhs0zVY8oA-d4AaABAg", "comment_text": "You’re awesome \nThank you 😊", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@Humancompassion1234", "username_md5": "dbb23a3c6c67a709980dab94d33429f6", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Humancompassion1234", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCupENhQlEMGrdSmSLbKmmdA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzdVBPAYLgioCZLdD54AaABAg", "comment_text": "This is so interesting", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@Reque92", "username_md5": "80915f5d199b053eedd4743d4662bcba", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Reque92", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCOdQ9JPWbeL6s3m_rbYvOHQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxExIXU18jND6FPgch4AaABAg", "comment_text": "600 BC - First Olympic games", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@jeliazkodimitrov3235", "username_md5": "e8808be3b1b28ed50cfac5a43e0074c2", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@jeliazkodimitrov3235", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCcaZbfJnKFJgcg8byQEEYoA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugw_XtJCwvZzM4DeWnh4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Great", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@TheMysticPete", "username_md5": "f7b3dfc7b8e48da9f1aee63712fe5ea1", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@TheMysticPete", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCaW5vt8I_tiWbA7K-eR3K4g", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgysCKC1pn86dC51c3x4AaABAg", "comment_text": "you are a god to me", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@pavel7674", "username_md5": "9a55394b7b2e990510bc11f99797e8ed", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@pavel7674", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCXsGCyLJmAPFAyllZ2ei8OQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwwFsEJyXx8LjEvkQ54AaABAg", "comment_text": "Is a history of science timeline on usefulcharts? I search but not found what i look for. I am interested in how science appeared as we know it today and who and when contributed to its development. I am also interested in a parallel with the discoveries and researchers from ancient China.", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@FAR-SOFT", "username_md5": "2ffc3ea5cb7f649852b2db853b49bcff", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@FAR-SOFT", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCtK69co8_MaFnJIn-0-4blg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugx78nwWnvpYiZBBFPt4AaABAg", "comment_text": "My wife got me the book for Father’s Day. I recommend it for anyone watching these videos.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@Agemus6139", "username_md5": "47e956c726d1eeb54cd01d2471d0467b", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Agemus6139", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCYb_IGNDGGKHJN__6sat2dg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugxi4zok3v3oKy338Vd4AaABAg", "comment_text": "So useful!!", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@benheideveld4617", "username_md5": "045153c21951fab8f32fe5237d9a4091", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@benheideveld4617", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCg07hR9ISgoj2h7atye6ELA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwYY46ppW_f7mlvfSN4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I thought it was interesting that you failed to mention Ireland at all when your section title was Britain/Ireland it makes it seem like they existed together until Irish independence mentioned at the bottom. Also, Scotland just appears out of nowhere without mention of previous civilizations like the Picts.", "likes": "3 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@timd9798", "username_md5": "66547ec5303cd5260623568a288e94bb", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@timd9798", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCpBdlBYJOpCd9LOClB30sEg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyAxwRWQt70h7uDlQd4AaABAg", "comment_text": "good work", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@terencenxumalo1159", "username_md5": "a2a9025dd05c6d2ad0b344ef72314df7", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@terencenxumalo1159", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCb2v9h9X3-vgscpl6f3urPA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxQSv5MI40aJNpw2qZ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Fascinating, thank you. CJ", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@carolinegodden4364", "username_md5": "6bf6b73ef049ff7a208450039f1860c2", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@carolinegodden4364", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCD-9cd8Sk2UE8oChYxSWglQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugzk9u2hIDZgHMr7Njl4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Ok of my teachers has two of your charts In her classroom", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@steakfilly5199", "username_md5": "ddd5b8a0e8b565d2859ae7b27d6ed821", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@steakfilly5199", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCITXWxndZswSISzuyDZkDEQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwH7KddPeqBHjBKKF94AaABAg", "comment_text": "Gotta admit this video really did come when I least expected it. I knew it would be a while with the widening gap between individual releases in this series, and then especially after he remastered the Asia video with Rackam I literally stopped thinking about it after a while.", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@joshygoldiem_j2799", "username_md5": "ab79058fab7cdd2296d45d29c63a7465", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@joshygoldiem_j2799", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCkDJf3vanpI8a7X93Pqv1mA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxiBIz6zn9bOGQ6PYB4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I just ordered my chart I'm so excited, 🎉🎉", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@MargaretJ90", "username_md5": "107e6df4ac188e257d827185f2acedcf", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@MargaretJ90", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC72kkOYO9tF3Vty_cuTYVyA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugx7fyHP9BaIQq809gl4AaABAg", "comment_text": "2:35 I have never seen a more confusing wipe, lol. You \"return\" to the future, by moving up the page (on which the direction of time is down) while wiping,", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@ChannelMath", "username_md5": "60436a4e35214183941e60898aa7f3e9", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@ChannelMath", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCeM04N-gVy9o8C9yga_vHtQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxVmH7Wcc609MBsUVZ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Hey, history lovers🖐️", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@loveOrLeaveMe", "username_md5": "fc9c377d76608906e04f2e6e45c57781", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@loveOrLeaveMe", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UChS9L6yJgsyihmdfi-emQkQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyV-vvxUNEQGKY51WV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "You have made many videos on different civilizations and people all over the world and they are all interesting. Could you include the Sami culture in Sapmi, northern Scandinavia and Russia. I think it would complement the Germanic culture and how Scandinavia was populated!", "likes": "4 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@ages6592", "username_md5": "53a07b9d8ca3c12b90d48d904d8b801a", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@ages6592", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCwJeQRi26fc66nFRUWgmyDA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwkdDYotMff2ehP5Ol4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Would be nice to see one like this of the continent America (north and south)", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@fedejr712", "username_md5": "40829ed0f4e32300fb7afa2cc13319ae", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@fedejr712", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC94ckqkgS4oGN-dnmm1_Raw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwPP3COcsRpN5EOXr54AaABAg", "comment_text": "Why did you kill Portugal in the chart? Lol", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@fernandodeaguiar7516", "username_md5": "ca543f48d06f9ea7dde47f6ebfee0b9e", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@fernandodeaguiar7516", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCxLfN3c8k6i2wCOcYJk9Pyw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxrQuHFL4Az65IeOh94AaABAg", "comment_text": "I'm sorry, what? Louis XVI was not Louis XIV's grandson, they're like 5 generations apart.", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@loganroy3381", "username_md5": "7b0c004cf731675653f175b04bb81ceb", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@loganroy3381", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCzQtIidzWpMf0TZSaxgZlQw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxzgGFN1uIJfVRpRqR4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Good video", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@-RONNIE", "username_md5": "b5107dda40e8252659684fd53af78b87", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@-RONNIE", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC7EBaS3tpKawT58TSYjJcwg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzpzFXJSl7GguchLxB4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Poland doesn't exist anymore, I didn't know... 😢", "likes": "11 likes", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@bananaforscale1283", "username_md5": "3599e70d73c74cfbda662c7ba1f41426", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@bananaforscale1283", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Portugal also evaporated into thin air....", "reply_like": "5 likes", "reply_id": "UgzpzFXJSl7GguchLxB4AaABAg.9g2YRFHrqYg9hAVAEJAdaN", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCtgeQ48eryJqW15K19plbDQ", "user_id_md5": "dfcf6d7c54a4962eba3bcdd2fa5b3bbf", "user_name": "@joaomramalho1", "user_name_md5": "cf4aa927615e1141cfa4c6385a60f730" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCT8C6Gl-cZOQQqBq3Q1uV0A", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwYhe0NE45sXxy0gtJ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Very good.\n\nSlavs however don't belong to group of those migrating from Asia.\n\nIt's about the same time (Actually Avars made the push to move Slavs) but their place of origin is on the border of current Belarus and Ukraine.\n\nFar from Asia, yet place often overlooked\n\nYou actually have the blue vs orange map - and there where those two population end on the East - Balts (north) ans Slavs (center) lived", "likes": "6 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@petrskupa6292", "username_md5": "0b0a24a1e36418266e7c0d858b467c5b", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@petrskupa6292", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCiwGLO3AQyk_QYrTh-8fQ4w", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxoS2l0N-F5sT73hrd4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Italy was unified in 1861, not 1871. In 1866 joined Veneto and in 1870 Rome. But the union was in '61.", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@CherriesPictures", "username_md5": "9c759d8c87aacc8eae7e6d82b7e55165", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@CherriesPictures", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC6_YOZPjP1_MY0F4O29avMg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxlobeA_ROEDBd4gbh4AaABAg", "comment_text": "6:55 Avars, Bulgars and also Khazars were direct offshoots of the Huns so were the other Oghur Turkic tribes of the Pontic Steppe ; Akatziri, Onogur, Utigur, Kutrigur, Saragur, Sabir,...", "likes": "8 likes", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@nenenindonu", "username_md5": "805305186b2432b6c67627a0fde3616e", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@nenenindonu", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Turkic peoples were really important in history of Europe :)", "reply_like": "5 likes", "reply_id": "UgxlobeA_ROEDBd4gbh4AaABAg.9g2Drfyrq619g2E2MHnk8I", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC0OLRsqi1FNexCogxuqp3hA", "user_id_md5": "5780b8b1aa671852a94a6e6caae65445", "user_name": "@papazataklaattiranimam", "user_name_md5": "67865fa0413481bc5d87808b8d99fcf5" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCFj_VAxHaJ3ug_VIN5aeCFw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugw2a_uZXeXpDUwln3J4AaABAg", "comment_text": "If you like this, check out \"Chronology of the World\" by Isaac Asimov (famous for his science fiction writing).", "likes": "3 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@billbauer9795", "username_md5": "fc68bc0a1a09e026ebd726711927dc8b", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@billbauer9795", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCE4q5FZYwtVIqL4L8QnMzLw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwyB5k5AsPrvsocjGJ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Interesting charts!", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@christineolivia8730", "username_md5": "4a59a61d001a534fb5e8a13f9e5bcdca", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@christineolivia8730", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCre3ByL2IPn-ibCqLbj4Wgg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzHCiz3pMnLIW8TB954AaABAg", "comment_text": "Kievan Rus and Kingdom of Ruthenia just slipped into first prince of Moscow und eventually Russia. impressive", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@pav0cristatus", "username_md5": "d9efa893cbee8015eb044074eeb26fcb", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@pav0cristatus", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCfcmtJnRqENugUiWlkgoyfw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugxo6nvRF83s9vJUsv14AaABAg", "comment_text": "A small correction: Rurik was either not a Scandinavian, or he did not exist at all, since Rus was mentioned long before the 9th century", "likes": "4 likes", "replies": "8 replies", "username": "@albertixthegreat792", "username_md5": "68869f2b52d07f641171b0986517c6f7", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@albertixthegreat792", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "The Rurikid dynasty was of Germanic Viking origin :-)", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxo6nvRF83s9vJUsv14AaABAg.9g2MHLB360U9g2Qf4mp4VD", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC0OLRsqi1FNexCogxuqp3hA", "user_id_md5": "5780b8b1aa671852a94a6e6caae65445", "user_name": "@papazataklaattiranimam", "user_name_md5": "67865fa0413481bc5d87808b8d99fcf5" }, { "reply_text": " @papazataklaattiranimam  no, this is not. Byzantine emperors already in the 7th Vela indicated that Slavic Rus existed. That is, German Russia never existed", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxo6nvRF83s9vJUsv14AaABAg.9g2MHLB360U9g2RnSdOe9a", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCAILpQl_ZO0uwaQJDga_c1g", "user_id_md5": "ea23c4bd34ef4dab45cf07c73e093360", "user_name": "@albertixthegreat792", "user_name_md5": "68869f2b52d07f641171b0986517c6f7" }, { "reply_text": "What sources do you base that claim on?", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxo6nvRF83s9vJUsv14AaABAg.9g2MHLB360U9g49AigRe-m", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UC9Bhb84QILur72cjeoJ0aqw", "user_id_md5": "5b2befbefbaa78fad2416dd7f8d6c333", "user_name": "@nisseheim4996", "user_name_md5": "d453c3393e146edb5c31accf3b22e0dd" }, { "reply_text": "Given that the only mention of him comes from one source written centuries later it is basically speculation", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxo6nvRF83s9vJUsv14AaABAg.9g2MHLB360U9iizsoTYmNV", "reply_rank": 4, "user_id": "UC6Kkaj7aPNuZA2_btf55JAA", "user_id_md5": "23d2e1571b778be2bf12cf19288b745c", "user_name": "@sebe2255", "user_name_md5": "bf22f8e49691b23285e8cd434269b467" }, { "reply_text": " @albertixthegreat792  Slavic dynasty of Germanic origin", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxo6nvRF83s9vJUsv14AaABAg.9g2MHLB360U9g2SSOi5Xgz", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC0OLRsqi1FNexCogxuqp3hA", "user_id_md5": "5780b8b1aa671852a94a6e6caae65445", "user_name": "@papazataklaattiranimam", "user_name_md5": "67865fa0413481bc5d87808b8d99fcf5" }, { "reply_text": " @papazataklaattiranimam  not German origin, it was Slavic origin", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxo6nvRF83s9vJUsv14AaABAg.9g2MHLB360U9g2SwQTPFOv", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCAILpQl_ZO0uwaQJDga_c1g", "user_id_md5": "ea23c4bd34ef4dab45cf07c73e093360", "user_name": "@albertixthegreat792", "user_name_md5": "68869f2b52d07f641171b0986517c6f7" }, { "reply_text": " @albertixthegreat792  I said Germanic (Norse) not German", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxo6nvRF83s9vJUsv14AaABAg.9g2MHLB360U9g2THNhLtMk", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UC0OLRsqi1FNexCogxuqp3hA", "user_id_md5": "5780b8b1aa671852a94a6e6caae65445", "user_name": "@papazataklaattiranimam", "user_name_md5": "67865fa0413481bc5d87808b8d99fcf5" }, { "reply_text": " @papazataklaattiranimam  and not Norse", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxo6nvRF83s9vJUsv14AaABAg.9g2MHLB360U9g2V9GmMsPx", "reply_rank": 4, "user_id": "UCAILpQl_ZO0uwaQJDga_c1g", "user_id_md5": "ea23c4bd34ef4dab45cf07c73e093360", "user_name": "@albertixthegreat792", "user_name_md5": "68869f2b52d07f641171b0986517c6f7" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCAILpQl_ZO0uwaQJDga_c1g", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwUu01nbAE1HBNRweJ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Thanks for the wonderful chart and great explanation. One thing I'd like to say is that at 14:49, Dutch war of Independence was during 1566~1648. So the [Dutch Republic] begins one hundred years earlier than this chart. And the Dutch Golden Age is during mid-1600s and is to be before the War of the Spanish Succession. One of the reason of the decline of the Dutch Golden Age is thought to be the Dutch involvement of the War of the Spanish succession. So after the War of the Spanish Succession, Dutch Republic existed for a while but its influence was greatly diminished.", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@teddybear-g4k", "username_md5": "4020450ca9c52c0f48d58689a4f83b56", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@teddybear-g4k", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCmhaWNNWDnEPiXaEFWpGlsQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugwx7_VZZdo-ndut8aZ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I wish you were shipping to other places besides Canada and the US :(\n\nIn any case, i love your videos so much! \nToday we had a company hang out, and a group of us were talking about history. At some point, i mentioned your channel, and people subscribed immediately :)", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@iDarkBladei2", "username_md5": "486da100fe3a3b42b287cd3a8a5d2643", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@iDarkBladei2", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCdmUTKK5df0w-he25Mz3mXA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugw-MbfD_1x3c2TTHOZ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "A masterpiece, so dense and yet so accessible", "likes": "7 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@HebaruSan", "username_md5": "3f4bc3be8c5199dcbcbdce1a29edbc99", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@HebaruSan", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC1Bs2xvCddrQp-reV1MQqDg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugwk0-9LZ7ToySTkFVV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "💙", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@rtpnzs", "username_md5": "5f2a71df5d423d4e94f14b5860e2197a", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@rtpnzs", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCWdr78lCwgUvFElrUJeMnmg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwBKbTcni-Wpbqmxpt4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Switzerland and Liechtenstein simply did not give a shit in all of these.", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@merckmaguddayao6814", "username_md5": "52506349190190833102daf7ba1c4cef", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@merckmaguddayao6814", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCFHZtix-zsR8bwX5S9Ab_fg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzAc00L0_l4ETpWKMx4AaABAg", "comment_text": "One quick note: the Roman Empire in the east lasted until 1453 when Constantinople fell to the Turks. The reason I say this is the term Byzantine Empire was unknown to those living in the eastern Roman Empire. Even up the fall of Constantinople they would never have called or considered themselves to Byzantine, they were Roman.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@anthonymaddox6515", "username_md5": "7967731078c7e97481a9b640ff03599c", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@anthonymaddox6515", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCzWNNjVI_POB5h8vQmhXYVQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyDow55ag0Ut5S6g1N4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Correct me if I’m wrong but he said Louis the 16th was the grandson of Louis the 14th which isn’t true. Louis the 15th was the great grandson of Louis the 14th and the grandfather of the 16th", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@jamesnewport-haas4575", "username_md5": "af272bc9b8b74e78c635e16f7ce9b01f", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@jamesnewport-haas4575", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCk2e6SrO3lghO_cCu4vJuvA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxhOdIP1ePpAu6zza14AaABAg", "comment_text": "My copy is winging its way across the ocean to Wales as you speak!", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@cennethadameveson3715", "username_md5": "fd01c90aa6de9293ccb1d39306cd65a3", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@cennethadameveson3715", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC1bGnLHcWRLrPrso6fNcWOA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugw-6IhdaG5eXK6FRLp4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I would love a chart of European cultures from the paleolithic aurignacian culture to the bronze age minoans. If that is to large of a time span you could start in the neolithic with the Yamnaya, EEF and WHG.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@wowjack8944", "username_md5": "77ca813f1d5898010ca8ec76cc80328e", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@wowjack8944", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCvfIQbgNcQ-7btnpKEF7bsA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugw2aNbMWRMlWeujITB4AaABAg", "comment_text": "mmm... Polish lack of reappearance doesn't make sense. Moreover it's line should be bit more prominent... almost like France's\n\n(I am not Polish, just considering it from point of its prominence in Europe)", "likes": "4 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@petrskupa6292", "username_md5": "0b0a24a1e36418266e7c0d858b467c5b", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@petrskupa6292", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCiwGLO3AQyk_QYrTh-8fQ4w", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxIhNtcniyVQt0-lNl4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Thanks for another great video. Does your book being shipped worldwide or just to Europe or North America?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@Drewciv", "username_md5": "9c819780c22f6044234b643dae6eeb0a", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Drewciv", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCJa5i09m39w--Sijpk5sFgA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugzsk3WbWnu8RHHmQ514AaABAg", "comment_text": "I am a bit late, but the Dacia and Thracia is completely missing", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@CS.08-i5g", "username_md5": "279a0d25e5251956591608a52a6419c6", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@CS.08-i5g", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC34YWavEx8O5ExYOQyLj8qw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzPQtXaX4Dyu8GPivJ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "The Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth surely deserves more than a blurb. We were the first country in Europe to have religious freedom and a Parliament that kept the Monarch in check.", "likes": "86 likes", "replies": "6 replies", "username": "@Stephanie_Vincent", "username_md5": "b8a39e1e5955df05c0287dc98d5f0b29", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Stephanie_Vincent", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Poor Poland. Overlooked. Overrun. Always in an existential crisis in history. At any point in time, does Poland exist or does it not? Who could say? 😅\n\nThe Polish-Lithusnisn Commonwealth has ended up fairly badly understood in the West, especially in the Americas. It's largely a result of the Cold War, it seems. The same goes for the Bulgars, Romania, and Hungary. I suspect it's just a result of the fact that Western bloc historians were not conducting much research in Warsaw pact countries for many decades. \n\nWhy this hasn't been repaired yet, however, is a mystery.", "reply_like": "7 likes", "reply_id": "UgzPQtXaX4Dyu8GPivJ4AaABAg.9g3kL7Wimh_A3Ja_FYPbRP", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC_WC1JytdEdtiJL28imFf5w", "user_id_md5": "87960b942f399cdc1f8fa24db1eb058f", "user_name": "@Robespierre-II", "user_name_md5": "be7ae7414711aca5ab9b3f9c491448c0" }, { "reply_text": "Nope, not the criteria. It's based on how prominent they were politically and historically, not their values.", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgzPQtXaX4Dyu8GPivJ4AaABAg.9g3kL7Wimh_AD336YOlIVF", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCkDJf3vanpI8a7X93Pqv1mA", "user_id_md5": "8dbd96c381eca99a31be034d15ab50a7", "user_name": "@joshygoldiem_j2799", "user_name_md5": "ab79058fab7cdd2296d45d29c63a7465" }, { "reply_text": "He also gave one sentence about the Renaissance. Don't feel too bad", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgzPQtXaX4Dyu8GPivJ4AaABAg.9g3kL7Wimh_ADBU5jXvLPL", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UCs1EApX1SsAd1iBL473ynaA", "user_id_md5": "a448ea33d7fa3ccaaa3a91c2a9197256", "user_name": "@Mateo-et3wl", "user_name_md5": "967dc15dbfb1eaf57e1e9775361fe229" }, { "reply_text": "You were part of that country? You were the country?", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgzPQtXaX4Dyu8GPivJ4AaABAg.9g3kL7Wimh_A5PsigKZQRO", "reply_rank": 4, "user_id": "UC3idxUVGhp_Ae1DBWkpipeQ", "user_id_md5": "bcd765c8a900d71f7b17125efef79730", "user_name": "@FedeNGI", "user_name_md5": "eb9b16a55a480d8eeed34dc308def261" }, { "reply_text": " @FedeNGI neither British people alive today did the things in the timeline, nor Italians French or Germans. All those people in the timeline are dead. How is this a reason not to include Polish history lol", "reply_like": "5 likes", "reply_id": "UgzPQtXaX4Dyu8GPivJ4AaABAg.9g3kL7Wimh_A6HNwDpqVgI", "reply_rank": 5, "user_id": "UC-VguYDuh6jAINkymtk9PKw", "user_id_md5": "e834ac46e0e085d18b9e8e73c347a213", "user_name": "@marcobelli6856", "user_name_md5": "587720511787ee5df861aa39f8317271" }, { "reply_text": " @marcobelli6856  I never said they did. But the person I'm answering talked about the past using \"we\". I don't care of which country is she talking about.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgzPQtXaX4Dyu8GPivJ4AaABAg.9g3kL7Wimh_A6HOoHZGy__", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC3idxUVGhp_Ae1DBWkpipeQ", "user_id_md5": "bcd765c8a900d71f7b17125efef79730", "user_name": "@FedeNGI", "user_name_md5": "eb9b16a55a480d8eeed34dc308def261" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCKsPGg-ujFP6gryiRFvGgIg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugzt_0kxdOyCcArH5EN4AaABAg", "comment_text": "id really like to see you do a video on the Pitcairn islands and how they decent from the mutineers of the bounty", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@Raygunexplosion", "username_md5": "afb2c6db4fb8fff02420554a612fb3ee", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Raygunexplosion", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCcHchS82ug56lObjSsXoC1w", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxPCgeBTBT7liMdi554AaABAg", "comment_text": "So... Poland does not exist to this day?...\nInteresting, indeed :/\n\n1918, November 11th.\n\nAnd generally all Central, Eastern and Southern Europe almost just do not exist to you. It's like historian equivalent of westplaining. Shame.", "likes": "3 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@ale-rr5lh", "username_md5": "e7781711a234a6fe198935b7a6a70f55", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@ale-rr5lh", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC_eFQMRYak5m9pui7fGKUrw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugwx1cA3czCCBL9w4214AaABAg", "comment_text": "There's also the European history poster chart, which also covers European history.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@candyneige6609", "username_md5": "cf03cbf8aa8326be3a0aa0e5f33e7a18", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@candyneige6609", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC412GwI1uNANuHOSK1Z8t9Q", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugy3UqWnni8jFVUD4zd4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I'm a bigger admirer of your work. I've learned a lot thanks to your work on YouTube. Thanks for that. On 7:46 the \"Byzantine Empire\" is mentioned. As we know now that is actually the Roman Empire with the capital being Constantinople (named by the Roman Emperor that ordered it build). Byzantium was the old name and belonged to old civilization, not Roman. The \"new\" Roman Emperor (German) in his political negotiations with the Pope wanted the Romans to be called Byzantine but that's not correct historically. In my opinion has we are aware of this we shouldn't call Byzantine to who are the real Romans. It's like perpetuating a political lie.", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@jpviegas2000", "username_md5": "44d2c33ed692056a12017abafad08744", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@jpviegas2000", "date": "1 year ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCa79khpRDK3EM8SQXm2TY8g", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugz_ShN3CGKEDLEA2u94AaABAg", "comment_text": "Please make the korean samsung’s group family tree", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@dis9465", "username_md5": "da3acc7aa72c26d954db968ea112c2c1", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@dis9465", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC6J60rY0QheFUFKqSSweKtw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugwmmbzkk1uvVKgpEB14AaABAg", "comment_text": "I wish you delivered to Australia :(", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@Daniel-sb7ze", "username_md5": "69e20b4a2856111f70ab9846c8e5bbd3", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Daniel-sb7ze", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC56QGIuNHmk8iIpMlipsTsA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzLh4nf5Y0d7FUQY-B4AaABAg", "comment_text": "These overviews of history are so compelling! I am mostly interested in the global and European timelines--the ones I find engaging in light of my ethnic heritage and my current intellectual interests. I understand history soooo much better by beginning with a birds-eye summary. And I deeply resent the perforated patchwork, ahistorical hopscotch, mortally censored mess called history we were given from about 5th grade through 12th (ages 10 to 18). We were farcically expected to see some sequential logic in this story, shredded-and-taped-into-brain-glazing incoherence though it was.\n Only now, 63 years later, am I stumbling through an organized chronicity with conterminous geography, offering the scaffolding of this thing I now treasure--An understanding of civilization. \n I still long to fill in many details--but this no-nonsense outline, even in its brevity, offers a grasp of origins, salient milestones, watersheds of great import and moments of pivotal change. I can tell myself, anyway, which meanings are concordant with which developments, and what future purposes can be wrought of history's grand sweep of endeavors, events, ideas, disasters and achievements. It's a journey that could actually head toward a happy ending, at least if people of good will win the day, and we're not collateral in the ambitions of Putin, Xi Jinpeng, Trump, Assad or Lukashenko.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@prototropo", "username_md5": "11505d36c88b49960a70fbc1d6c11fe8", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@prototropo", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC57fQRcb8puwVl6z-zawjew", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxSzigD74zx_jXHB4N4AaABAg", "comment_text": "12:45 I know it’s a bit picky, but during the bubonic plague the speculation is around a third than half of the population. I know it differs from 20 to 50 million people, even so the most historians assume it’s around 20-25 million people and about the third of the population at that time.", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@wisses1805", "username_md5": "1beeedc16eb1b8572ac884eecd6a4ad3", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@wisses1805", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCqj6v5bXHPDZlC0bXNJxOHQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugz4K04udwx86zrk7M14AaABAg", "comment_text": "I thought a group of Norse people were the settlers/founders of the Kiev Rus kingdom.", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@ryanvoll7088", "username_md5": "82a413ccb2c7beff851b9bdc27032cc4", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@ryanvoll7088", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCZTwTVkZW9-JyHNJyk8nCGQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugxj0U3cYAy9jsEm1QV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "One big problem, you do not tie up Rus with Vikings/Norse which is the same, Rus came from Roslagen/Roden (little north of Stockholm)", "likes": "6 likes", "replies": "4 replies", "username": "@roxpace", "username_md5": "9eb6e26dda6294f97050c20dbda8e085", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@roxpace", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "I agree, Rus Vikings are as important as the Normans in Normandie.", "reply_like": "5 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxj0U3cYAy9jsEm1QV4AaABAg.9g2NLRxdOhk9g2qw4OV8yL", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCTeUKqpT1U3MezvEuhG192g", "user_id_md5": "4ee5f6a1ea3eddae6891eebb50fb0d7f", "user_name": "@reineh3477", "user_name_md5": "715b7086ab72d54283812c9bbd33c819" }, { "reply_text": " @reineh3477  How does connecting their ruling class to a different region matter that much? It is not like the Rus were majority Scandinavian, or that the Normans were majority Norwegian", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxj0U3cYAy9jsEm1QV4AaABAg.9g2NLRxdOhk9iizS62wRj2", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UC6Kkaj7aPNuZA2_btf55JAA", "user_id_md5": "23d2e1571b778be2bf12cf19288b745c", "user_name": "@sebe2255", "user_name_md5": "bf22f8e49691b23285e8cd434269b467" }, { "reply_text": "It's not a big problem. These charts are just basic overviews of more major powers. The chart would be too messy if you included every little thing. Alot of nations came and went. While moving around/crossing with others and so on. It would need alot of lines going everywhere. xD", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxj0U3cYAy9jsEm1QV4AaABAg.9g2NLRxdOhk9g2bDW4ghAm", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UCt60JAkODzLKy9eb49sg6Yg", "user_id_md5": "ee8bbbc66ac04e95d977653d5abc191b", "user_name": "@MeldinX2", "user_name_md5": "dd4de3a865645695f55222513737d081" }, { "reply_text": " @MeldinX2  Removing what Rus people are is pretty big, I understand you as well.", "reply_like": "3 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxj0U3cYAy9jsEm1QV4AaABAg.9g2NLRxdOhk9g2iVs8kP6r", "reply_rank": 4, "user_id": "UC4eQeCsjKWBpIDj_7ohJn7Q", "user_id_md5": "2cde9481ee988bcab32306f8bc57af57", "user_name": "@roxpace", "user_name_md5": "9eb6e26dda6294f97050c20dbda8e085" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC4eQeCsjKWBpIDj_7ohJn7Q", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzJpDpwIzkksaKZUs14AaABAg", "comment_text": "Where is Portugal after 1640 to this date? Portuguese came to become the 3rd most spoken European language as a native language. I think this chart made a monumental mistake, even by Anglo Saxon standard. Please CORRECT the chart!", "likes": "3 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@olhovivocdb6355", "username_md5": "47f98b54075180012d40ae5dfdd29699", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@olhovivocdb6355", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCMiJ_Sw26D_LD9Eq9s5hrPA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugy8UsqthxG7Pm4HJbR4AaABAg", "comment_text": "This is so unrelated but when I play football manager, i manage AS Roma.\nMy goal is turn this club into a Dynasty. Dominating European football, just like the Roman Empire dominated Europe. \n\nI call it the “Roman Empire” challenge.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@alohatigers1199", "username_md5": "66141698cf524af4b10942ff3e670ca8", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@alohatigers1199", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCm58H5VRmwCgMx-bjozDy3Q", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugx4ZRMOprmau3br5XN4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Can you do a chart of the Romanian monarchy ?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@7Hellzz", "username_md5": "6421f29a346d9ffebf600ce09a4c7dd5", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@7Hellzz", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC1ZbTW78Wp6Ge5w3Ji2TXJQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzLDOxwQQTG10TR5mN4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I love how the history of Rome just seems like a small part of european history with everything else going on. And I am going insane making the roman succession tree. My life is consumed by it right now ^^'", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@GanoGaming", "username_md5": "4b079fbe3e5496427b84e6c9eeb18d21", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@GanoGaming", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCvmmWZthk5DmmrhTaG3h1jg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzwGVbWqQlW_XJeJON4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Hey the webpage to buy the book isn’t correct :-/ can you please give me the new link?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@arvindradhakrishnan4773", "username_md5": "c7aeeb7174d1752b511fad00a3705241", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@arvindradhakrishnan4773", "date": "9 months ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCZry7QoXWj4zvebXqofrq0A", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugw-cvdpu_2m4DR0b8R4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Wait the Macedonians did not conquer the Spartans", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@ethan8942", "username_md5": "b04b69d5e57dd27c7cd147bc43a51244", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@ethan8942", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCb5IxGJ6n8BaPydJ2Wh7bXA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzS5dv06vaPJcACwEp4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Shouldn’t there be a line from the Vikings to the Kievan Rus?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@jbjhoosier", "username_md5": "0f6047d73daaa14f236271bfc6b6ac6b", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@jbjhoosier", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCGF5ffkw4hY4glX8pcYvnsA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugw-SgxVRpjcblmlp714AaABAg", "comment_text": "You missed the information about the Thracians. They are before the Hellenes.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@yavory", "username_md5": "3bd78eeaee3ac1924035dfd626ba760e", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@yavory", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCZHCRdf9Ml8SLgFrcFobPaw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwDU3v9cHZb0lf4MTx4AaABAg", "comment_text": "did Sophocles (playright) get corrected to playwright?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@kaciebroadfield262", "username_md5": "cb39666e3db690ab1812ddf84ccca0aa", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@kaciebroadfield262", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCsdoQmfUSb1QeqE_lyb2Srw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyKFC_XQiy-TRatoMd4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Portugal doesn't re-emerge from the union with Spain?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@MatthewMcVeagh", "username_md5": "ac786dfb4b3331381f2ee74b168101a8", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@MatthewMcVeagh", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCK3vQ8lZIPlhh9s9xQIDZ8A", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwHfq4G2jLxASHdHVh4AaABAg", "comment_text": "no mention of the repulic of turkiye?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@inkt_", "username_md5": "0dc72b32e5ac43a7d3ddef21e8559af6", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@inkt_", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC-z2Robmvb8k7LmPgq9c5VQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyRhr9zIdE8ji85geV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "please do burmese monarch chart", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@shinthanthtooaung3454", "username_md5": "4e28acd9b888e9c4fd89378c6bf07bd8", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@shinthanthtooaung3454", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCpsPad4jIKZjZvAimXo_Ojg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzEzyzfstVwJHfn4W14AaABAg", "comment_text": "What's happens with Romania whiseguy? 😒", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@rumondux2922", "username_md5": "4d8e673b5403e5355e5b1a797afb5fa9", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@rumondux2922", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCn5rnomGl0eKYNDNOHYr2TA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxY-9VodaHYuZCep_N4AaABAg", "comment_text": "This map is not available as a poster or?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@maurokjr984", "username_md5": "9812263246fb633608a0ff1cc106b50d", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@maurokjr984", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCZNmC1Oo9RmEmzn__JMlq9Q", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwRrwtinlQVP4i0SDh4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Antarctica never gets any respect.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@TheDanEdwards", "username_md5": "77849b4289824170057f86eaafea6875", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@TheDanEdwards", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC1oRorD3VLtqqAQaNmEL36Q", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxUm-8br49NBWVgMuJ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I would also add about the almost complete Ottoman, and what would have probably been Islamic expansion into Europe, stopped by the Kingdom of Poland (+ HRE)\n\nStopped at the Battle of Vienna 12 Sept 1683, its also noted as the largest cavalry charge in history\n\nAs well as casually being the turning point of a 300 year struggle between the Ottomans and the Austrian Habsburg\n\nI'd say pretty significant in European history\n\nThe book looks amazing though!", "likes": "17 likes", "replies": "4 replies", "username": "@MaximAmadi", "username_md5": "813b00e9e2ca93eee2327ef392316b8c", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@MaximAmadi", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "More so stopped by the HRE helped by the kingdom of Poland.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxUm-8br49NBWVgMuJ4AaABAg.9g3IK-Cqhd69iiz6L3Zkyx", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC6Kkaj7aPNuZA2_btf55JAA", "user_id_md5": "23d2e1571b778be2bf12cf19288b745c", "user_name": "@sebe2255", "user_name_md5": "bf22f8e49691b23285e8cd434269b467" }, { "reply_text": " @sebe2255  Why? The polish charge was decisive there.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxUm-8br49NBWVgMuJ4AaABAg.9g3IK-Cqhd6A-4EDaIk0vW", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCCmwAHC80EAqkz7ihxm1r6g", "user_id_md5": "53d9ec30ab37daf546480e75c424f833", "user_name": "@alekm5646", "user_name_md5": "5b40ac03283365952852d3fd3dbcfcdf" }, { "reply_text": "winged hussars were a minority in the army, most of the war was won by the generals of austria. i think its overglorification as many other counties glorify their historical victories (similar to the charge of the light brigade which was actually a total lie unlike this one)", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxUm-8br49NBWVgMuJ4AaABAg.9g3IK-Cqhd6AKOyFnNmKgU", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UCD3aBRznr5dTE-O2QCKLKTA", "user_id_md5": "4c755b4fc501b24f105ee61e2b9cd3fa", "user_name": "@adelite", "user_name_md5": "937890f37b5b1c25995667a86b9caa08" }, { "reply_text": " @alekm5646  Because Poles didn’t eveb make up a majority of the relief army, most were troops from the Empire. And they weren’t even the first in the charge", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgxUm-8br49NBWVgMuJ4AaABAg.9g3IK-Cqhd6A-4T3PJzyvp", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC6Kkaj7aPNuZA2_btf55JAA", "user_id_md5": "23d2e1571b778be2bf12cf19288b745c", "user_name": "@sebe2255", "user_name_md5": "bf22f8e49691b23285e8cd434269b467" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCKQWuMKiVhqvNSGZLC9c3Ng", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzNJo0y8xw2zWYJk_54AaABAg", "comment_text": "I have been meaning to buy your limited edition British Royal family tree, but I've been hesitating because I wondered if it might be updated with King Charles III?\n\n If not, I intend to get it anyway, but I didn't want to miss my chance to have an up-to-date one.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@sadaasdafa8635", "username_md5": "7095da1fe9e087dcf31980be43e1ca32", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@sadaasdafa8635", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCE3Vtjrg2056fzuMe9-P7TA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxLx9pYM33LSNZmzo14AaABAg", "comment_text": "Do video on South India kingdom's", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@robinsaju5539", "username_md5": "d2b3b28a26bc2a2e5554d084c69bc2c0", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@robinsaju5539", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCLQAkjofan6Kiybo8nqeymw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzUYRX95GoJKLE5ysN4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Please make more Who Wrote the Bible? videos! For instance, one on the Samaritan Torah (more akin to the Book of Mormon video for that though).", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@Sqk.", "username_md5": "6361107bfb465b9016822918cf5c0584", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Sqk.", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC-jJAvV9PnrC3WErjeLBz7g", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzskbV6ijZ7-mQH1JB4AaABAg", "comment_text": "People in the comments: \"There's no Portugal at the end! There's no Poland at the end! You didn't talk about Kievan Rus!\"\nMe in the meanwhile: \"Oooooh, there's Moravia! We are relevant! <3 <3 <3\"\n:D", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@alenaalisakomendova", "username_md5": "80ef0566bea984cea223635dba0fce0b", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@alenaalisakomendova", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "But you have to admit it’s ridiculous. Poland is 20 Slovakias and Portugal was one of the top global empires for another 300 years....", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgzskbV6ijZ7-mQH1JB4AaABAg.9g400dbUiIX9hAVqb-rBZO", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCtgeQ48eryJqW15K19plbDQ", "user_id_md5": "dfcf6d7c54a4962eba3bcdd2fa5b3bbf", "user_name": "@joaomramalho1", "user_name_md5": "cf4aa927615e1141cfa4c6385a60f730" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCRvDDDwOG1bIcN29X6dzirw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwxPm45zGEKJe4damB4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Ireland never became controlled by the Romans, so the chart is a little off, there are a few other things which are easy to find corrections for on the net, but its a good chart despite its issues.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@HaastTalon", "username_md5": "b19697807e32ce95ccbe8d97491a0707", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@HaastTalon", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCXBstGckfQZJjjdT0e63fuw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugy-3pwxybs1fCg-6sh4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Am I understanding that the Vikings way back were just one of the Germanic tribes?", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@debraturner4559", "username_md5": "a1dd5c56ca5594ce72358c508f3afb59", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@debraturner4559", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "The Scandinavians are the original Germanic people so yes.", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "Ugy-3pwxybs1fCg-6sh4AaABAg.9g7GWP0LYoB9grQdcc9_gz", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCHx3KNWY62yVoKf5gfFQ9hg", "user_id_md5": "78086eac97585e9758d5664314b43658", "user_name": "@tonyhawk94", "user_name_md5": "39a2582005dac9d174220cf54fb9e6a8" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCf6OR0Uqu-F41WNxafeDaMw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgypGs72RgQsy6Ja0rR4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Technically Norway was Mostly independent from 1814 Sweden-Norway was Just on foreign policy. something which Norwegian politicians at the time hated the end of the union with Sweden started when Norway tried to start up their own consulates in the 1880s. Military was independent from the Swedish military.", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@PeterBuvik", "username_md5": "9813c2565f92f796728316147889d285", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@PeterBuvik", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCGvBgT5qfpkmUzYzlZL6TIQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugwrs83ehZ4lncrewS54AaABAg", "comment_text": "\"Out of Stock\": Is this book going to be restocked?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@MarkPray-p7h", "username_md5": "328b7f276781275eeb81f992329f967f", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@MarkPray-p7h", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Yes. We just ran out. Should be more in stock in a few weeks.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugwrs83ehZ4lncrewS54AaABAg.A6RkqU3F4LDA6RtGNle7jd", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC7o-UFkoAPCoKxpKOfrs4zQ", "user_id_md5": "a366c1459fcd0648a338ac5cf5fdee9a", "user_name": "@UsefulCharts", "user_name_md5": "a8e1a413c0185bb94ef44fe26398ce83" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCHcpbvlN8aYYissHe4FmdyQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzaHP6zTPgazhaDywl4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I love to study and read history. Sadly shipping of ur items are not available in india. 😢", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@gayathrya2482", "username_md5": "bcfa8f455136c03590b455be425b95bb", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@gayathrya2482", "date": "11 months ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCcjMt9RAYpjewBmaU06OHfA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwXKpsQdqdMpjvcZEp4AaABAg", "comment_text": "This book and the mini charts look amazing! Just put it in my Amazon cart!", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@wackywagners3463", "username_md5": "08fc5c9e72e02191d8cd87ec66302609", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@wackywagners3463", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC-PWqQ8OplWpjVstVVOv15A", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugz7b3jfbCqPJDt8RJt4AaABAg", "comment_text": "These are not avilable anymore?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@kraks11", "username_md5": "86f0c85ff33622c9ef4557e88119002e", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@kraks11", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCr11JPL7vJ37WnvgPmcfeQw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugzpjp_sRr6onUshM754AaABAg", "comment_text": "This chart ignores today Romania and the Baltic states", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@liviusandu2947", "username_md5": "d391ffd33d044b8ee8498314609c53d1", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@liviusandu2947", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCXEZ0tt8pVZ_CxUw5nW2mgA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzHMz_n4LFMYEu37dZ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Hi, this chart is a great job. \nJust a little correction : Louis XVI, who was the king during the French Revolution was not the Grand-son of Louis XIV but his great-great-great-grand son : Louis XV was the great-grand son of Louis XIV, and Louis XVI was the grand-son of Louis XV... Anyway Louis XVI was the direct descendant of Louis XIV....", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@sebastienlaithier3807", "username_md5": "11d4e08246d1825ec35a77a5d8412556", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@sebastienlaithier3807", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCOAocvbg6zET_8E898t5-Aw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxFQ1tLM6SL3aWtp8l4AaABAg", "comment_text": "25$ chart costing 51$ for shipping...🥺\nChildren of only rich can afford to pay 76$ for 1 chart.😩\n\nWhat a time we r living in...\nEducation is bcmng item of luxury only.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@hyperzchannel8972", "username_md5": "a1fbf54fc02b84de6d8a235a771a9c3c", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@hyperzchannel8972", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC6J2Pr-l01wmRnnEKOu0QbQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugzx1nj8oqsHCHOq39p4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I love yor map sbut there is no sense of not showing the line of Portugal the Iberian Union. Thanks anyway.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@pedromeloico", "username_md5": "83ceabc3d3cdb9f1ee775e964f6cfd64", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@pedromeloico", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCbqINaSyun6QT2G_-kwrzIw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugx12Hk1cCCUzeWBaVF4AaABAg", "comment_text": "\"..ironicallty both Sparta and Athens were eventuallty conquered by the Macedonians.\"\n\nWhere is the irony?", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@SoLazy100", "username_md5": "95498eebadd272d325fe72da4beea70e", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@SoLazy100", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCunKMVBaThdSX5SXDj5oaIw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyxXbUH28McPrgLadF4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Will you be doing slight alterations to the British monarchs family tree now Charles is king?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@EmilyCheetham", "username_md5": "c8848b32bfbd04eacd49d9ebc0e76317", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@EmilyCheetham", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCerPysxgAi1KM_oyxtTA1cg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyWZHioJqaZvYlem6t4AaABAg", "comment_text": "In the guitar world there's two different shape cutaways, mostly identifiable on the les Paul. The florentine and the Venetian. Do you know any stories about the stringed instrument rivalry that went on between these states at this time?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@scottbogfoot", "username_md5": "c8eecb2190831f43a337f4c49a688d7c", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@scottbogfoot", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCfhjz2Jc_Ov27EqnIsejemQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxwS8QNR37gzIV1P-V4AaABAg", "comment_text": "15:41 🇹🇷🌝", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@papazataklaattiranimam", "username_md5": "67865fa0413481bc5d87808b8d99fcf5", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@papazataklaattiranimam", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC0OLRsqi1FNexCogxuqp3hA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugy8a_5BK5o2BbYDyZV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I have a question relating to lines of successions. What if a King has twins. They would be both the oldest descendant of the monarch. Who would legally inherit the throne if the king dies and didn't have the time to appoint a successor? Thanks.", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@JimonWheels", "username_md5": "76dfff10195fd830cdbe8cd2268c0bf3", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@JimonWheels", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCuDIPmGL3Krr6xPheK9f5rw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugw1qQLL0XrgUj3TPmt4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Maybe do a video about the lands of modern Ukraine through time to show who has held the power of the land when, where and how long. ^_^", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@nicolinemunk6904", "username_md5": "ea0a89b0edd466eaf2ea67a309467285", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@nicolinemunk6904", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCnr4QusyIjSnXrTsvRetUug", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxL0HBaatq7SYxx01R4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Whats your Source for the first Habsbuger King ?I am living in a City that was esthabilished 1296 as a free Reichsstadt (Self-Governance Rights) by Rudolf the first from Habsburg, if you have book you could recommend id love it. thanks for this Video great Work", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@shitshow2061", "username_md5": "4a33f7681479e40546cbb309275c1ee9", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@shitshow2061", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCcYAMKy8WomCPXcJhW_ZFuw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwDqhedUFQOOGto8Rt4AaABAg", "comment_text": "How would the Etruscan civilization fit on the chart?", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@misterpi3.14", "username_md5": "c343d9519fb5aad2b583edfdddbf12e0", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@misterpi3.14", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Etruscan culture span from IXth to IIIth century BCE when they were pretty much absorbed by the Romans. Their territory was (mostly) constrained to what is today north Italy, so they would be a small line parallel to the first Rome one, although they weren't the only player in Italy at the time.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgwDqhedUFQOOGto8Rt4AaABAg.9g2pJvfsHDA9g7RFwS3sxX", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC8mwaW5k2-jiWZNDGxZNyrQ", "user_id_md5": "86af76ac0ad5270fd11150e8ed51203a", "user_name": "@kes1709", "user_name_md5": "7d99e009f6f7d0f08019b794602429fc" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCIwiaBXT-485D12g-5m9QqQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwJSBaFQIbUBfRLQPV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Is there any chance you would build a chart of PSEUDOSCIENCE....? It would be fascinating to see how these modern charlatans are all networked together. There's a history of modern people using 19th and early 20th century pseudoarchaeology to justify all manner of bizarre theories, many of which bleed right into white supremacy (from an era of eugenics and direct control of much of the planets population during the colonial era). It is a very hot topic on YT and elsewhere right now, especially with Joe Rogan and expert practitioners of pseudoarchaeology like Graham Hancock (many of his \"theories\" originate with Ignatius Donnelly, Blazatsky, von Daniken and Sitchin). It would be a great service to real science to have all of this produced on a single chart showing where the origin of each theory comes from, going back to Plato. Thanks for your consideration. Cheers! PS. I love your work.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@richlancaster8336", "username_md5": "08b9c461e45d02a14dd63ee3f4afdd81", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@richlancaster8336", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCYHceCFwYWCEcBS_quSVqLQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzLQj0D0yuvAQh7KI54AaABAg", "comment_text": "Hello can you make a trace Philippines royalty?. balangay era like rajah sultan datu?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@sesnando", "username_md5": "fb9de4bba72c30e3328982b0d2b5f7d7", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@sesnando", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCnUsXFCiXBP6r7n9hg5dFiQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugx1JLsH9Y_IzNP4AtZ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Do who would be \"\"king\"\" of India or whatever", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@tardwrangler", "username_md5": "50f599a896af7c73812c35c8bd78012f", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@tardwrangler", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCYwSP3X-OiK4haDsSCMB2Tg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyGepe3x8jH2mMWNQh4AaABAg", "comment_text": "It does not have Portugal, this chart is not a good historical reference.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@ruimineiro746", "username_md5": "09eea33e4c7cd8a193cd0eef14f2d0cc", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@ruimineiro746", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCMQrRQGdkxRxyGmvd043Evw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxYmwkAlUWG_bLzhNh4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Germany gets purple?!? angryface :D", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@fabiankempazo7055", "username_md5": "1382e1d7e816211ffe271850364b51fe", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@fabiankempazo7055", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCPw_W8orYOiaYWos4ns5W8Q", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwbXoCz7XRZuDp5zi14AaABAg", "comment_text": "Is it helpful or annoying to point out a typo at this stage? :)\n\nAt about 15 mins", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "2 replies", "username": "@weavehole", "username_md5": "35d15800ad2bfacbd178d170dbc98fc8", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@weavehole", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCT4clsJC0KSBS4FYXUejHZQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugw6kI1PZTTYNAZFZXV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Love your videos :). What software do you use to make family trees? I would like to make my own but there are so many of them and couldn’t find one that fits me. Thank you.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@broskynaleo3233", "username_md5": "fdf928b5c6de70b839f33d9b3848e669", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@broskynaleo3233", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCCpt8J15uaSWMVAjirK1jng", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgywZUoM1uSuqlxX9El4AaABAg", "comment_text": "13:08 Louis XVI was not XIV's grandson, but rather his great-great-great grandson (two generations of dauphins died between XIV and XV, and one between XV and XVI.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@UnoriginalHandle", "username_md5": "345690f72d789a86d4c673b04eb16c09", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@UnoriginalHandle", "date": "1 year ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCym9cSwKGPf_VFQn6kFMUGg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwoxpahpF7GLQ3pW2J4AaABAg", "comment_text": "First", "likes": "3 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@Angelgreat", "username_md5": "30e6a257ba92b57eea193b55543a6962", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Angelgreat", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCnGsv4tB2f6a5bYgiH-P8ow", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwC0Bf501-w33JcD314AaABAg", "comment_text": "Finno- Ugric tribes according to Herodotus were indigenous people in land of modern Moscowy 500 BCE- 1240 AD --> After Mongol-Tatar horde invasion it was \"Ulus of Jochi\" 1242-1502 AD --> Tsardom of Moscowy 1547-1721 AD --> Russian empire 1721-1917 AD --> USSR 1922-1991 AD --> russian federation 1991", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@apprentice-i9l", "username_md5": "750a414ebd1fdb7ada46bf8a88f2c27a", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@apprentice-i9l", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCgozfC9oE0SWhYcnqlJYo7Q", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwE3EexiX0D5zmLUVV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "What I find interesting is how could the Jews have never known what they were headed for. I find that very peculiar.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@kforest2745", "username_md5": "fe4d23fca42be73acbcad9645cb492f3", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@kforest2745", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCb5teyYEswoLzuA3PZOt0qw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxV6qRnc8YeTpLoKJl4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Look for the French king who rules with the Pope in the end of the age", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@cecelialeroux4408", "username_md5": "5965d7cf2f3b2320cfd5cab5053fdbcb", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@cecelialeroux4408", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCN7ZZqyd_MZRCIZAepgzN2A", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwU1o0_JxOc94IWqd94AaABAg", "comment_text": "vikingr is an occupation, a job.....", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@opussum9813", "username_md5": "0f0801976079d0486f543002e8051c65", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@opussum9813", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCPxTb77ZjlzG3wlXNUuQltA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugxopsbj30NifHlGHgx4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I will forever be indebted to you you've changed\nmy whole life continue to preach about your name\nfor the world to hear you've saved me froma huge\nfinancial debt with just little investment, thanks\nso much Mrs. Kathy Wilson", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@onwechinwenkwo", "username_md5": "72b3afff4d4c387c4f45f1d08274a202", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@onwechinwenkwo", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC40VbWr_NmqVjaBne6-NTXA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwN8YLPL3eMM86j8GV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "This is great except your missing important bits. You can’t just role Ireland in with the uk and say job done. Huge mistake! There Isn’t room for everything but there is room for Irish history.", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@JodytheBrien", "username_md5": "a99cda787053451208456a0b684a2359", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@JodytheBrien", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Ireland wasn’t a major player in European history.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgwN8YLPL3eMM86j8GV4AaABAg.9gL88FEfhHv9gRE33a8aSt", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCVynKhN0fOw7QnLJDd-IM9Q", "user_id_md5": "8ce5277b4f98a0acbc49768f6e3764c6", "user_name": "@arberor4597", "user_name_md5": "fd61f5702f886dd7c182a1fc10b9acff" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCyqRYWIQOzeQhOI06gWfOkA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugwicg3gk3uvVYsOQtd4AaABAg", "comment_text": "The tsars flag is flying in Russia again so the monarchy has it back in it's control.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@EXHIBIT-AOK", "username_md5": "193af7605ba9f8eb60d333ec4af035b9", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@EXHIBIT-AOK", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCztaA7MgNMisZ8_6CvVQz3g", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugw0CbL-jjgsngZ7STV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "ΕΔΩ ΕΙΝΑΙ ΣΠΑΡΤΗ! Speaking of east and west. I fo shoo dint went to (opsec) and there was not a piece of the great wall off berlin and fo shoo i dint touched it with my own permission. Imagine if napolion won everything and we all speak spoke sacré blé.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@TommiHonkonen", "username_md5": "366f7ad8a85698f6deb341600e30819d", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@TommiHonkonen", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC1iJO97VPm6cEhQ07bntmPw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxDnIvYTve67go8XmF4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Can you do video about Bulgaria, like their monarchs etc", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@Sokk_era", "username_md5": "1e1eeb700c932b0cfd206929d27b8d02", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Sokk_era", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC764Wgy8F-kCOMWXofHMXbQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwwXWqtLppINHXqVJd4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Alupigus! Where's the thracian civilisation and theire descendants? The romanians? Whyseguy?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@rumondux2922", "username_md5": "4d8e673b5403e5355e5b1a797afb5fa9", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@rumondux2922", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCn5rnomGl0eKYNDNOHYr2TA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzSScsk1nOFOqB3zON4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Ignoring Eastern Europe is a fatal flaw if you covet a holistic understanding of history.", "likes": "31 likes", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@shitpostinc.4544", "username_md5": "d616ba04760ca535edf14078adcae98f", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@shitpostinc.4544", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCXfjQlpJpQIyX23M7mFfnWQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxNaX5fvNpzTTMUZZF4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I bought this book. \nIt's annoying that I can't remove the little charts! I already ripped mine because it wears down from folding/unfolding so quickly. An I've had the book for only a few days maybe a week. It's just so annoying! I'm fixing to just rip the charts out. Lol \nI got a couple other small complaints but other than that I love the book. I haven't read all of it yet but seems good so far. 👍", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@marcopolo2418", "username_md5": "8d1323044dd5b250ac0b937989199165", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@marcopolo2418", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCWCtlqd_joCBUYA8lwPbG9A", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwBJKS1fb7sEVOZdZZ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Any idea when the book will be back in stock?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@autisuna8725", "username_md5": "d72d0d57ed0a40c2df6c131deb11d39b", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@autisuna8725", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "By the end of October", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgwBJKS1fb7sEVOZdZZ4AaABAg.9gTgQoIIF1B9gUYIXmRnQU", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC7o-UFkoAPCoKxpKOfrs4zQ", "user_id_md5": "a366c1459fcd0648a338ac5cf5fdee9a", "user_name": "@UsefulCharts", "user_name_md5": "a8e1a413c0185bb94ef44fe26398ce83" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCEr4fneej4Jx-OVN7lGB1Rw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwevdTQZSRO-SN3VI14AaABAg", "comment_text": "Where is Illyria which was settled by oldest people in Europe. Even today DNA of Bosnian people shows that most of them are Illyrians (older people) and not Slavs that came from the north which were Croatians and Serbians. Illyria is missing.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@vedorap", "username_md5": "ef58b85e418ab37143327bf29902b020", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@vedorap", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCCTl-zPRdySVBHPGrexcvnA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugy4nlJgW8TpFEQcqJd4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Turks indeed had a decisive role in triggering historical major events like the Migration Period, Crusades, Age of Discovery as well as ending the Middle Ages with the conquest of Constantinople, fall of the Eastern Roman Empire.", "likes": "12 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@papazataklaattiranimam", "username_md5": "67865fa0413481bc5d87808b8d99fcf5", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@papazataklaattiranimam", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC0OLRsqi1FNexCogxuqp3hA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxlL2BwZFxqDq_1bil4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Too bad Portugal & Hungary disappeared long ago...", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@brooksmagruder6662", "username_md5": "ab03f0d02f49ff356eb3019f3db63e1a", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@brooksmagruder6662", "date": "2 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCroHJh1FNjZaF39vjoZs4zQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzBo2qKp-HYKLcgn_R4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Ok number one it’s not fact to say a pandemic killed all those people that’s poppycock. It IS fact to say they weren’t taking care to ensure robust immune systems. It is after all a time of war. War is accountable for every death not a so-called “virus.” Believe me you’d see the picture if you’d seen what I’ve seen.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@kforest2745", "username_md5": "fe4d23fca42be73acbcad9645cb492f3", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@kforest2745", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCb5teyYEswoLzuA3PZOt0qw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyF9CgshI7FqQPoE2d4AaABAg", "comment_text": "The Angevin empire wasn't (in any way) an \"English\" empire. This is a misconception. That empire was centered in western France, were the royal court was (in Angers, thus the name \"Angevins\"), and the kings of England weren't English. The kings of England were powerful because they had other titles, in France, not because England was especially powerful.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@xenotypos", "username_md5": "42299f7cc61ddea548f4bda551868b15", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@xenotypos", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCRcn6P20ktDH2MnyyCWDacA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwzYSD-TfaTfozWq_J4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Why did the line of Portugal ended after the Iberian union? The way its done makes it seem like Portugal no longer exists.\nI understand that space is important, but other smaller countries are still there.", "likes": "5 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@TitusRex", "username_md5": "50bee950ad15917b7cce6799be179a67", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@TitusRex", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCSHsorFIevVcKvR1vD6-GgQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzlDvDfv7WRbdHg8U54AaABAg", "comment_text": "Bro, did you just show Portugal getting absorbed by Spain and not becoming Independent ? 😭😭😭😭", "likes": "11 likes", "replies": "2 replies", "username": "@FilipeSilva1", "username_md5": "44483cf5243ef44cd5774cf8c253c552", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@FilipeSilva1", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Portuguese history deserves at the very minimum a little line there.", "reply_like": "4 likes", "reply_id": "UgzlDvDfv7WRbdHg8U54AaABAg.9g2Gh9mjOJk9g2GvxcKnGp", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCI8lNd9uXr79DTD9p3FT2Pw", "user_id_md5": "bfb5b600a67aaa046b833cb444040f28", "user_name": "@FilipeSilva1", "user_name_md5": "44483cf5243ef44cd5774cf8c253c552" }, { "reply_text": "And he liked the comment “RIP Portugal”....Fucking hell!", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgzlDvDfv7WRbdHg8U54AaABAg.9g2Gh9mjOJk9hAW1Ke-AG_", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCtgeQ48eryJqW15K19plbDQ", "user_id_md5": "dfcf6d7c54a4962eba3bcdd2fa5b3bbf", "user_name": "@joaomramalho1", "user_name_md5": "cf4aa927615e1141cfa4c6385a60f730" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCI8lNd9uXr79DTD9p3FT2Pw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxTMb28yCaSamRjzSV4AaABAg", "comment_text": "14th amendment equal protection of nations at UN international law turn over to God free will sovereignty as divine central authority unity for two state solution separation from West human sovereignty", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@jamesruscheinski8602", "username_md5": "e8c9660cd8ad20f0ee470824858af6dd", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@jamesruscheinski8602", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC02YloMhXdpTsLbE6VkR03g", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugw7FEpsdHdlXmaeWKp4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Just for clarity, at the end of the Hungarian line, it's says \"throne inherited by Hasburgs\" but you say Habsburgs, is this a spelling error or an error with the pronounciation? Not sure if there are both Hasburgs and Habsburgs is all 😊", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@aidenlee-flanagan4486", "username_md5": "d3f08dbf9f9fc82517d0f08506252951", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@aidenlee-flanagan4486", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "That is a spelling mistake", "reply_like": "2 likes", "reply_id": "Ugw7FEpsdHdlXmaeWKp4AaABAg.9g2wffV3k1p9g6__8ob9UQ", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCPJVGdvyOSs3Ff7PEDISprQ", "user_id_md5": "30558ecd5ad3c0b65f3415b4cc776f44", "user_name": "@lucabohn", "user_name_md5": "f16b6e7adbb1ac09c84ee2cd214d371d" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCt58_0wU5GBS6NScnOQlVlQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgylJPmAynIrvqwz7hB4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Excellent channel. May not be completely accurate but no one will know everything anyway it’s history. I’d never visit Europe the behaviours are toxic the ideologies pathetic so it’s not surprising the countries made up of mostly European descent are creating a “dystopian future” as per Canada’s recent complaint about Carney who’s no doubt of European descent and Canada that is over 50% European lol", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@kforest2745", "username_md5": "fe4d23fca42be73acbcad9645cb492f3", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@kforest2745", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCb5teyYEswoLzuA3PZOt0qw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyqZF2lII9dLNzpiCZ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Gobekli Tepe 10,000BCE. 👋", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@GildaLee27", "username_md5": "1cec9b64c4f1bc1d549b8f96f70b85b5", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@GildaLee27", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCGCUlaDu1SoGumMtajyhdbA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugysn9uHE1uphpacLPd4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Really what aboit us the balkan people ? Nothing ?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "2 replies", "username": "@cgt3704", "username_md5": "746bb170cd6b6390186028ee0b44956b", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@cgt3704", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "The most important dynasty of Balkans was Dulo though", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugysn9uHE1uphpacLPd4AaABAg.9g2QXmiEXjM9g2Sgv3hw5W", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC0OLRsqi1FNexCogxuqp3hA", "user_id_md5": "5780b8b1aa671852a94a6e6caae65445", "user_name": "@papazataklaattiranimam", "user_name_md5": "67865fa0413481bc5d87808b8d99fcf5" }, { "reply_text": " @papazataklaattiranimam  i think this honour should be given to the Asens instead. The Dulos were more turkic than slav or latin", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugysn9uHE1uphpacLPd4AaABAg.9g2QXmiEXjM9g2TYwKB1ui", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCjgXI7VuTedMvpjfj7667CQ", "user_id_md5": "6d1f2e92154f926e9fac6e4c9a6823e4", "user_name": "@cgt3704", "user_name_md5": "746bb170cd6b6390186028ee0b44956b" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCjgXI7VuTedMvpjfj7667CQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyKu0qEjpVfeO1GRbZ4AaABAg", "comment_text": "The Turks too , the great warriors of the steppes , were almost haughty in the assumption that they inherited the jihad fighting spirit of the tradition and carried it half - way into Europe . \r\n\r\nTurko-Persia in Historical Perspective p.94\r\n\r\nDuring the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries , understanding the Turks ' military organization , given the credit for the greatest empire since antiquity , became a major European preoccupation . \r\n\r\nSpeake, J., n.d. Literature of travel and exploration. p.891.\r\n\r\nBy the middle of the 16th century, the Turks arguably possessed the greatest empire in the world. \r\n\r\nA History of the Middle East Paperback – March 15, 2006 by Saul S. Friedman (Author) p.181\r\n\r\nIn the west the Seljuq invasion of Asia Minor began the process which was to make it the modern land of the Turks and the base from which the greatest Islamic empire of the past 600 years would expand into southeast Europe .\r\nMacEachern, S., 2010. The new cultural atlas of the Islamic world. p.32.\r\n\r\nTHE TURKS AND THE WEST. Europe stood in awe of the Ottomans who crushed many states and conquered vast territories, going, as all patriotic Turks will proudly point out, \"all the way to the gates of Vienna.\" European literature is replete with the depictions of the Turk as the hated enemy. The English often thought of the Turk as awe-inspiring and destructive. Thomas Fuller wrote in The Holy Warre (1639): \"The Turkish Empire is the greatest... the sun ever saw. ...Grass springeth not where the grand signior's horse setteth his foot.\"\r\n\r\nHalman, T. and Warner, J., 2007. Rapture and revolution. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press, Crescent Hill Publications, p.9.", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@papazataklaattiranimam", "username_md5": "67865fa0413481bc5d87808b8d99fcf5", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@papazataklaattiranimam", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC0OLRsqi1FNexCogxuqp3hA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzZWfJ3pKUkksdUOMp4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I know you have a lot to cover but from Scottish point of view the chart is mince. We did not get taken into the Roman Empire or then just appear again 1000 years later. \nAs for Ireland, they too were never taken into the Roman Empire and then seem to only appear to exit the British empire.... 🤣", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@falconfotographic", "username_md5": "c58e00133e75d178b3658c5e1ddba271", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@falconfotographic", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCm3JQI9mfES0u9XvcU2sDbw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzxASxZ5NxS_iEwsMd4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Also, in addition to the evaporation of Portugal, Celtic Iberia is erased from history by a couple of Phoenician trading posts...", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@joaomramalho1", "username_md5": "cf4aa927615e1141cfa4c6385a60f730", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@joaomramalho1", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCtgeQ48eryJqW15K19plbDQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxgMulmteCrE20nbup4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Also, Bulgars were never Turks. Because, how on your theory, they became Slavics so fast? After some 10 years?)", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "5 replies", "username": "@albertixthegreat792", "username_md5": "68869f2b52d07f641171b0986517c6f7", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@albertixthegreat792", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Bulgars were Turkic but Bulgarians were Slavic, they weren’t same.", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgxgMulmteCrE20nbup4AaABAg.9g2NLT8HeD69g2Q_uOmBdr", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC0OLRsqi1FNexCogxuqp3hA", "user_id_md5": "5780b8b1aa671852a94a6e6caae65445", "user_name": "@papazataklaattiranimam", "user_name_md5": "67865fa0413481bc5d87808b8d99fcf5" }, { "reply_text": " @papazataklaattiranimam  ah yes, Bulgarians and Bulgars", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxgMulmteCrE20nbup4AaABAg.9g2NLT8HeD69g2ReLQmPy3", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCAILpQl_ZO0uwaQJDga_c1g", "user_id_md5": "ea23c4bd34ef4dab45cf07c73e093360", "user_name": "@albertixthegreat792", "user_name_md5": "68869f2b52d07f641171b0986517c6f7" }, { "reply_text": " @papazataklaattiranimam  ancestor of modern bulgarian were Bulgar Turks, they were same. The old bulgars became Bulgarians and Tatars today", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxgMulmteCrE20nbup4AaABAg.9g2NLT8HeD69g43XtydTZU", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UCyV91beDm9wVmLUdat-aBsw", "user_id_md5": "fb4866750c70f5b65221e161f8676d33", "user_name": "@milliyetci5672", "user_name_md5": "09c2767c64bef62c036df31ae314afbc" }, { "reply_text": "I never said Bulgars were Turks.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxgMulmteCrE20nbup4AaABAg.9g2NLT8HeD69g2NonONTC2", "reply_rank": 4, "user_id": "UC7o-UFkoAPCoKxpKOfrs4zQ", "user_id_md5": "a366c1459fcd0648a338ac5cf5fdee9a", "user_name": "@UsefulCharts", "user_name_md5": "a8e1a413c0185bb94ef44fe26398ce83" }, { "reply_text": " @UsefulCharts  Bulgars were Turkic people, later became slavic and get the name bulgarian", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxgMulmteCrE20nbup4AaABAg.9g2NLT8HeD69g43I11MSI9", "reply_rank": 5, "user_id": "UCyV91beDm9wVmLUdat-aBsw", "user_id_md5": "fb4866750c70f5b65221e161f8676d33", "user_name": "@milliyetci5672", "user_name_md5": "09c2767c64bef62c036df31ae314afbc" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCAILpQl_ZO0uwaQJDga_c1g", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzCYKNo3Mvyje1Wv4d4AaABAg", "comment_text": "You said the French Revolution occurred during the reign of Louis XIV's grandson. Well, no. Although Louis XVI was the second king who came after Louis XIV, he was the grandson of Louis XV, who in turn was the great-grandson of Louis XIV. So this means that Louis XVI was the great-great-great-grandson of Louis XIV. I'm pretty sure you already knew that, you probably just got carried away.", "likes": "8 likes", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@Saruman38", "username_md5": "f9a4a8bc1c4db740e27c9c1c94e17510", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@Saruman38", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Right! Good point.", "reply_like": "3 likes", "reply_id": "UgzCYKNo3Mvyje1Wv4d4AaABAg.9g2NiX1hZWw9g2OXmOatJI", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC7o-UFkoAPCoKxpKOfrs4zQ", "user_id_md5": "a366c1459fcd0648a338ac5cf5fdee9a", "user_name": "@UsefulCharts", "user_name_md5": "a8e1a413c0185bb94ef44fe26398ce83" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCJtz0ym0i7f8IPps0zyCthA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwHxMLQiXvP5QsdAoh4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Very inaccurate, especially when it comes to southeastern Europe. If it's the same in the book, it's not worth buying.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@kirilkirilov8161", "username_md5": "ae414e9c452eac0cf719fbe46f215fed", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@kirilkirilov8161", "date": "9 months ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCJUF0lKJmpdw1YfZFdn4aUw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwgxRbTv0lMZ08rG054AaABAg", "comment_text": "Why do you guys always say England was the world’s largest empire? Have you guys not studied the Mongolian Empire?!? Mongolia 🇲🇳 was the world’s largest empire! Genghis Khan ruled the world more than England could ever have done..", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "4 replies", "username": "@theamerican7408", "username_md5": "703741fdaeed623cd64c62c917deda3b", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@theamerican7408", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "The british empire at its largest extend did eclipse the mongolian empire.", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgwgxRbTv0lMZ08rG054AaABAg.9g4U21Hl4T99g4cbXc-s9J", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCVBg1sqpDFIjucLYgz2IOcw", "user_id_md5": "f0a9d20cebd0af51fb33df6fb059178a", "user_name": "@tirex3673", "user_name_md5": "5f0af04cdc9367157f0afd0c1b24f341" }, { "reply_text": " @tirex3673  how? England occupied in certain areas they didn’t conquer as much as the Mongolians did. I just don’t think you guys know much about them and you all focus so much on Europe history which is great but not completely factual. When you say England is and was the largest empire.. just because most people use the English language for international business reasons across the globe doesn’t mean England conquered the world as the largest empire.. if you say this then the United States Empire 🇺🇸 holds this power right behind the Mongolian empire. United States actually has US military bases and controls the global markets", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgwgxRbTv0lMZ08rG054AaABAg.9g4U21Hl4T99g5F3JUjkXm", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCKZW4daZEyFMb7_3p5Ai9UA", "user_id_md5": "e16267a9756a8ef59bd37d6e952e548d", "user_name": "@theamerican7408", "user_name_md5": "703741fdaeed623cd64c62c917deda3b" }, { "reply_text": " @theamerican7408  No, the British empire at its largest extent (in 1920) controlled a larger area, than the Mongols did at their largest extent (in 1270). The British back then most notably had Canada, India, Australia and an entire string of territories from South Africa to Iraq.\n\nThe Mongols had the second biggest empire after the British and the largest continous empire in history.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgwgxRbTv0lMZ08rG054AaABAg.9g4U21Hl4T99g5IyDjszbc", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCVBg1sqpDFIjucLYgz2IOcw", "user_id_md5": "f0a9d20cebd0af51fb33df6fb059178a", "user_name": "@tirex3673", "user_name_md5": "5f0af04cdc9367157f0afd0c1b24f341" }, { "reply_text": "​ @theamerican7408  What makes you think I'm American?\n\nColonies are parts of an empire, they are controlled by the same entity. If you think systems whose governments can be overruled by someone else, doesn't count as being controlled by that someone else, then OK. But Canada alone is bigger in area than the USA.\n\nNothing about the fact, that the British Empire managed to overtake it in size in the early 20th century, changes the impressiveness of what the mongols achieved. They conquered a territory including basically everything from Korea to Ukraine and then some.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgwgxRbTv0lMZ08rG054AaABAg.9g4U21Hl4T99gAyLHZrAgU", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCVBg1sqpDFIjucLYgz2IOcw", "user_id_md5": "f0a9d20cebd0af51fb33df6fb059178a", "user_name": "@tirex3673", "user_name_md5": "5f0af04cdc9367157f0afd0c1b24f341" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCKZW4daZEyFMb7_3p5Ai9UA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgymgqngiPJ0y2EJ9Cd4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Why do you skate over the real history. Why don't you mention about Armenian Kingdom? Or is it not your level of understanding?", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@narinemanukyan7078", "username_md5": "a1ca5b6957d20f01942ddadd822ba13f", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@narinemanukyan7078", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCvUGEbVrajpZeM5D9u2eGZg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyHHCjdvSTspak8dT14AaABAg", "comment_text": "This chart should have title: \"Timeline of WESTERN European History Foldout Chart\". Or you can do better with this timeline. \nYou are ignoring Eastern, Central Europe. You are including some plankton like Scotland, or Venice, or Nordic countries (small population for Nordic c.) but at the same time ignoring many Eastern European countries. \nPoland-Lithuanian kingdom (1,000,000 km2) was bigger than France, yet your chart is showing that was reverse situation. \nIt is Kyivan Rus NOT Kievan Rus (Kyiv NOT Kiev). \nPoland and Ukraine are now 2nd and 3rd biggest countries in Eastern/Central Europe. Both reappeared/appeared on map in 20. century. And both are BIGGER than Austria or The Netherlands. \nHungary should be next to Austria -- it will be easier to make a scheme. Hungary was part of Austrian Empire and then Austria-Hungary. Use colors for Austria and Hungary at least in the case of Austria-Hungary. \n\nSo you have a lot of work on your chart.", "likes": "4 likes", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@robertab929", "username_md5": "dcea68a5a4144fc9410ecc4c6c860a0e", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@robertab929", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCoDOSLRTbmsMQaF97OBwlzw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxYnQUGFGV3mM3W9R14AaABAg", "comment_text": "0:11 “.... we looked at THE AMERICAS???” So, how many Europes there are? And how many Asias? So, how many continents there are?There is ONLY ONE America and it’s from Alaska to Patagonia.", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "7 replies", "username": "@yutub6928", "username_md5": "9b1b7786bb44e22fc0690664e4280dac", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@yutub6928", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "well not since the french and the usa put a little canal in between", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxYnQUGFGV3mM3W9R14AaABAg.9g5vpXeFS-W9g7S5POWzAE", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC8mwaW5k2-jiWZNDGxZNyrQ", "user_id_md5": "86af76ac0ad5270fd11150e8ed51203a", "user_name": "@kes1709", "user_name_md5": "7d99e009f6f7d0f08019b794602429fc" }, { "reply_text": " @kes1709 , what do you mean? Canal?", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxYnQUGFGV3mM3W9R14AaABAg.9g5vpXeFS-W9g8M2F367ov", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCA0HOPHlSnvHADzmUl-feLg", "user_id_md5": "286f1be040592285bd5747fff5728da4", "user_name": "@yutub6928", "user_name_md5": "9b1b7786bb44e22fc0690664e4280dac" }, { "reply_text": "Okay ik its two years later, but North and South America are usually referred to as seperate because of the vast differences and Panama canal. So against the manmade arguement, Africa is seperate from Asia right? Well the Suez is manmade", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxYnQUGFGV3mM3W9R14AaABAg.9g5vpXeFS-WABbf4TSLlei", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UCUVLDJ23276e7eWj5pfOtOg", "user_id_md5": "f13cd88710e74cfa029be94e0ff0316e", "user_name": "@Polskakapibara_11", "user_name_md5": "73f887f8011a11afc3486e1285061764" }, { "reply_text": "Europe is a single peninsula, Asia is too big to quantify, there's only one consecutive Africa, the Americas at the very least have a recognised North and South.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxYnQUGFGV3mM3W9R14AaABAg.9g5vpXeFS-WACM04U0dqB4", "reply_rank": 4, "user_id": "UCgrUCb5AF4FMyL3eyZUsImA", "user_id_md5": "399fc890d37b3e2c100bc110b74f2b8d", "user_name": "@davestrider4973", "user_name_md5": "ea2f7b5ba6827ac22e891424d0521ee2" }, { "reply_text": " @yutub6928  the Panama cannel. Separates north and South America", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxYnQUGFGV3mM3W9R14AaABAg.9g5vpXeFS-W9gREZ2DzUUc", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCVynKhN0fOw7QnLJDd-IM9Q", "user_id_md5": "8ce5277b4f98a0acbc49768f6e3764c6", "user_name": "@arberor4597", "user_name_md5": "fd61f5702f886dd7c182a1fc10b9acff" }, { "reply_text": " @arberor4597 , when I firs saw the comment, it crossed my mind the Panama Canal but that is man made and a silly answer. As mentioned before, there is only one America from Patagonia to Alaska. And thanks for your comment. Keep well.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxYnQUGFGV3mM3W9R14AaABAg.9g5vpXeFS-W9gTMPQ0fDvo", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCA0HOPHlSnvHADzmUl-feLg", "user_id_md5": "286f1be040592285bd5747fff5728da4", "user_name": "@yutub6928", "user_name_md5": "9b1b7786bb44e22fc0690664e4280dac" }, { "reply_text": " @yutub6928  lol even the concept of continent is also man made. \n\nAlthough when talking about history and culture the Americas lack a level of connectivity. The Aztec and Inca didn’t even know each other existed much less natives in the USA and Argentina.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxYnQUGFGV3mM3W9R14AaABAg.9g5vpXeFS-W9gUBH1Fuga0", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UCVynKhN0fOw7QnLJDd-IM9Q", "user_id_md5": "8ce5277b4f98a0acbc49768f6e3764c6", "user_name": "@arberor4597", "user_name_md5": "fd61f5702f886dd7c182a1fc10b9acff" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCA0HOPHlSnvHADzmUl-feLg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzcKxGPvUXAqc15Opp4AaABAg", "comment_text": "It means you don't believe according to the bible that Human History on the planet started with Adam and Eve laid their feet on the planet Earth?\nYour entire narration is based on Archeology monopoly and kidnap of History!\nHistory doesn't mean only the Written Record!\nWhat about that RECORD treasured and cultured in the Human Hearts over the generations?\nIt's all useless knowledge proposed and imposed by a particular lobby and not accepted and respected by the majority of Humans!!!!\nLarkana Sindh Pakistan \nApril 10,2025.", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@professorengineermuhammads5556", "username_md5": "c787516e7c14cb433f45a30cf9cac375", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@professorengineermuhammads5556", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCbGpt8QHyn1B7oxKfNoaLSg", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugxrzc5DOwz6bA7wT6B4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Why not include Indo-European yamnaya early migration? Early European farmer and hunter gather Europeans merging to form the modern genetic linguistic European?\n\nSurely this is bias. The Proto-Indo-European and pre European languages and culture still play the biggest role in understanding genetics and language", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "3 replies", "username": "@TheMagicJIZZ", "username_md5": "afb75bbcfd499925e5d6d6b762388e7a", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@TheMagicJIZZ", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Because this video is about 800 BCE to present. Talking about European prehistory would certainly be great and I do plan to do that in the future but it's simply not the topic of this video.", "reply_like": "4 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxrzc5DOwz6bA7wT6B4AaABAg.9g2JLC9Zh0y9g2Jo1Z8DfR", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC7o-UFkoAPCoKxpKOfrs4zQ", "user_id_md5": "a366c1459fcd0648a338ac5cf5fdee9a", "user_name": "@UsefulCharts", "user_name_md5": "a8e1a413c0185bb94ef44fe26398ce83" }, { "reply_text": " @UsefulCharts  okay that makes sense, I'd like to learn more about the sky father concept creating the pantheon of Gods\n\nI found it interesting how Jupiter ( Deus pater ) is Zeus and similar to Odin, the sky father God seemed to replace matriarchy and introduce patriarchy\n\nA lot of people don't even think of the days of the week being named after Indo-European gods like wodin, Thor and freya today & Saturn tomorrow. Understanding how the pagan gods influenced city states and Mythos would be cool map", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxrzc5DOwz6bA7wT6B4AaABAg.9g2JLC9Zh0y9g2K_80IcoN", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UC_KTRulcc2sMICLD-Tnrynw", "user_id_md5": "6d7899d0d522d8afce0f45c92c471748", "user_name": "@TheMagicJIZZ", "user_name_md5": "afb75bbcfd499925e5d6d6b762388e7a" }, { "reply_text": "Bias in favor of what? A period we actually have sources for?", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "Ugxrzc5DOwz6bA7wT6B4AaABAg.9g2JLC9Zh0y9ij-Br-U1DH", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UC6Kkaj7aPNuZA2_btf55JAA", "user_id_md5": "23d2e1571b778be2bf12cf19288b745c", "user_name": "@sebe2255", "user_name_md5": "bf22f8e49691b23285e8cd434269b467" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC_KTRulcc2sMICLD-Tnrynw", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgzgVijo1Qe9DfpOvh54AaABAg", "comment_text": "And the last, Russia were made buy Tatars, and Russians were Finno-Ugric. Kievan Rus is just Ukraine, Grand Duchy of Lithuania-Belarus and Moscovia-Russia", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "9 replies", "username": "@albertixthegreat792", "username_md5": "68869f2b52d07f641171b0986517c6f7", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@albertixthegreat792", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "It's Lithuania and Poland.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgzgVijo1Qe9DfpOvh54AaABAg.9g2N_2g-tMY9g3i7ZA_G4R", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCKsPGg-ujFP6gryiRFvGgIg", "user_id_md5": "cd3199861b1b7dfd2ab21159726a63db", "user_name": "@Stephanie_Vincent", "user_name_md5": "b8a39e1e5955df05c0287dc98d5f0b29" }, { "reply_text": "Rus’ were Germanic and Russians were Slavic. I don’t even know what they have to do with Finnic Ugric peoples", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgzgVijo1Qe9DfpOvh54AaABAg.9g2N_2g-tMY9g2QmTAZbc1", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UC0OLRsqi1FNexCogxuqp3hA", "user_id_md5": "5780b8b1aa671852a94a6e6caae65445", "user_name": "@papazataklaattiranimam", "user_name_md5": "67865fa0413481bc5d87808b8d99fcf5" }, { "reply_text": " @papazataklaattiranimam  modern Russian mixed of Slavic, Tatars and Finnic Ugric", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgzgVijo1Qe9DfpOvh54AaABAg.9g2N_2g-tMY9g443u2dK-4", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UCyV91beDm9wVmLUdat-aBsw", "user_id_md5": "fb4866750c70f5b65221e161f8676d33", "user_name": "@milliyetci5672", "user_name_md5": "09c2767c64bef62c036df31ae314afbc" }, { "reply_text": " @milliyetci5672  yes. From Slavic people they gave only language, which was a dialect of Bulgarian language", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgzgVijo1Qe9DfpOvh54AaABAg.9g2N_2g-tMY9g6cZh6SsNw", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCAILpQl_ZO0uwaQJDga_c1g", "user_id_md5": "ea23c4bd34ef4dab45cf07c73e093360", "user_name": "@albertixthegreat792", "user_name_md5": "68869f2b52d07f641171b0986517c6f7" }, { "reply_text": " @albertixthegreat792  not true. You confused Cyrillic script with the actual language. Bulgarian spoke Turkic Bulgar language before slavization of Bulgaria. Modern Russian got slavic language from Kievan Rus. Russian language is Eastern Slavic came from Old East Slavic while modern Bulgarian language is South Slavic.", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgzgVijo1Qe9DfpOvh54AaABAg.9g2N_2g-tMY9g6dk1AR9LH", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UCyV91beDm9wVmLUdat-aBsw", "user_id_md5": "fb4866750c70f5b65221e161f8676d33", "user_name": "@milliyetci5672", "user_name_md5": "09c2767c64bef62c036df31ae314afbc" }, { "reply_text": " @milliyetci5672  another lie. Everything is much easier. At that time Bulgarian was the written language in Rus. When the Slavs colonized the lands of the Finno-Ugric peoples, the priests taught Merya, Meshcherya, Chud, Ves and Murom to read texts in the Bulgarian language. From here the Russian language appeared - a mixture of Bulgarian, Ukrainian and local Finno-Ugric languages. It turns out that the so-called Russian language is something like Esperanto", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgzgVijo1Qe9DfpOvh54AaABAg.9g2N_2g-tMY9g6eU0eQqz4", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UCAILpQl_ZO0uwaQJDga_c1g", "user_id_md5": "ea23c4bd34ef4dab45cf07c73e093360", "user_name": "@albertixthegreat792", "user_name_md5": "68869f2b52d07f641171b0986517c6f7" }, { "reply_text": " @milliyetci5672  also, it was proved that the Bulgarians were never Turks and they have nothing in common with the Volga Bulgars.", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgzgVijo1Qe9DfpOvh54AaABAg.9g2N_2g-tMY9g6eb33C0fB", "reply_rank": 4, "user_id": "UCAILpQl_ZO0uwaQJDga_c1g", "user_id_md5": "ea23c4bd34ef4dab45cf07c73e093360", "user_name": "@albertixthegreat792", "user_name_md5": "68869f2b52d07f641171b0986517c6f7" }, { "reply_text": " @milliyetci5672  this is nonsense, how Turkic people became to the Slavic people", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgzgVijo1Qe9DfpOvh54AaABAg.9g2N_2g-tMY9g6eeeNMoSq", "reply_rank": 5, "user_id": "UCAILpQl_ZO0uwaQJDga_c1g", "user_id_md5": "ea23c4bd34ef4dab45cf07c73e093360", "user_name": "@albertixthegreat792", "user_name_md5": "68869f2b52d07f641171b0986517c6f7" }, { "reply_text": " @albertixthegreat792  you'r such a troll. Proved by who? Founder of First Bulgarian Empire was Khan Asparukh. Modern Bulgarian ancestor were Turkic, later they slavized. bulgarian ancestor were slavic only in alternative history but in real history, they were turks.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgzgVijo1Qe9DfpOvh54AaABAg.9g2N_2g-tMY9g6jTTHli65", "reply_rank": 6, "user_id": "UCyV91beDm9wVmLUdat-aBsw", "user_id_md5": "fb4866750c70f5b65221e161f8676d33", "user_name": "@milliyetci5672", "user_name_md5": "09c2767c64bef62c036df31ae314afbc" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCAILpQl_ZO0uwaQJDga_c1g", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxLW1x4dxq0dQBwtJt4AaABAg", "comment_text": "It doesn't make sense to put Merovingian dynasty in german side. Even if Frank were German to begin they were very quickly absorbed by the vastly superior local Gallic population at the end of the reign of Clovis. For exemple it explain why French is a Latin language and not Germanic and that it has been influenced very little by the Frank language.\nWhen you go somewhere and you adopt the language, the culture and especially the local religion, it is more of an integration than a real invasion...\n\n\nThis also creates nonsense in the graph. How to justify that West Francia becomes blue again when it largely takes over the borders of the kingdom of Clovis which is in purple when there has been no migration or particular event ?\n\nYou did it correctly for England, when France invaded England,, even if they killed almost all saxons nobles to remplace them by French nobles who came fight, it doesn't mean all english population will switch there culture, even after 4 century of reign of French monarch.", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "7 replies", "username": "@azx43", "username_md5": "ed73e9e7844dddaebf6ea57fe204817f", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@azx43", "date": "3 years ago (edited)", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Also French, despite the name, does not linguistically descend from Frankish. Frankish certainly influenced the Romance language spoken in Gaul which led to it being called French, but for the true descendants of the Franks and their language you have to look at the southern Netherlands, modern day Flanders, and various dialects in West Germany. One of the earliest examples Old Dutch/Old Low Frankish, is literally written in the Frankish Salic law. The French for the most part just inherited the name because they managed to hold onto the Karling dynasty the longest. But their connection to the actual Frankish people, who are still Germanic today, is weak at best.", "reply_like": "2 likes", "reply_id": "UgxLW1x4dxq0dQBwtJt4AaABAg.9g2Mwnq1vB39g3pM-JeZtj", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC6Kkaj7aPNuZA2_btf55JAA", "user_id_md5": "23d2e1571b778be2bf12cf19288b745c", "user_name": "@sebe2255", "user_name_md5": "bf22f8e49691b23285e8cd434269b467" }, { "reply_text": "The Merovingian dynasty was of Salian Frankish origin, wh came from what is now Flanders and parts of Wallonia (that were still Germanic by this point). And it is a complete misconception to believe that the Franks all just moved and assimilated into the Gaulic population. This can be easily shown by the Karolingian dynasty still being a primarily Germanic dynasty hundreds of years after the Merovingian invasion of Soissons.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxLW1x4dxq0dQBwtJt4AaABAg.9g2Mwnq1vB39g3oraoxHX0", "reply_rank": 2, "user_id": "UC6Kkaj7aPNuZA2_btf55JAA", "user_id_md5": "23d2e1571b778be2bf12cf19288b745c", "user_name": "@sebe2255", "user_name_md5": "bf22f8e49691b23285e8cd434269b467" }, { "reply_text": " @sebe2255  Purple is said to mean present day Germany, not early middle age Germanic culture", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxLW1x4dxq0dQBwtJt4AaABAg.9g2Mwnq1vB39g7W8YHnwaZ", "reply_rank": 3, "user_id": "UC8mwaW5k2-jiWZNDGxZNyrQ", "user_id_md5": "86af76ac0ad5270fd11150e8ed51203a", "user_name": "@kes1709", "user_name_md5": "7d99e009f6f7d0f08019b794602429fc" }, { "reply_text": "Completely agree, however since both spanish wisigoth and lombard are also purple, maybe we shouldn't take the claim 'purple is present day Germany' too seriously. Frankish Empire should definitly be blue however, I mean Charlemagne father Pepin the Short and grandfather Charles Martel have nothing to do with present day Germany.", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxLW1x4dxq0dQBwtJt4AaABAg.9g2Mwnq1vB39g7VkZ6YZ5U", "reply_rank": 4, "user_id": "UC8mwaW5k2-jiWZNDGxZNyrQ", "user_id_md5": "86af76ac0ad5270fd11150e8ed51203a", "user_name": "@kes1709", "user_name_md5": "7d99e009f6f7d0f08019b794602429fc" }, { "reply_text": "The Norman's invaded England not the French. The Norman's (Northman) were Vikings who were related to the Anglo Saxons thats why they had a claim to the throne.", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgxLW1x4dxq0dQBwtJt4AaABAg.9g2Mwnq1vB39g2Qs6VSHrL", "reply_rank": 5, "user_id": "UCTkXICa-DPYIo7_Ln8JTkNg", "user_id_md5": "88ce861cec6153eafc0d582d19f714fc", "user_name": "@edgaralanponk", "user_name_md5": "7eef8f4d27369d96697eaea7b2f326fa" }, { "reply_text": " @edgaralanponk  Yes funny story. Very popular in the 19th century\n\nYou have a few thousand settlers invited to settle at the mouth of the river to protect it, in a region already populated by half a million inhabitants, but poof magically the whole region becomes Viking (even if once again, the local language, culture and religion has been adopted).\nGuys had maybe 1/32 of german blood but they are all german. Cool, racism is \"great\", but it's not really fit with science.\n\nMoreover at this time the head of the house of Normandy always takes a wife in Brittany, France or Flanders and most of the army of William the Conqueror has no links with any Viking history.\n\nFinally, the house of Normandy is replaced by the Plantagenet house which comes... from Anjou. Hard to find any saxons or stuff like that.\n\nIf you start with a logical, you must apply it until the end and with same rules for all.", "reply_like": "2 likes", "reply_id": "UgxLW1x4dxq0dQBwtJt4AaABAg.9g2Mwnq1vB39g2XZvW-id6", "reply_rank": 6, "user_id": "UCm4lBkeG_1-7D9xoHgpT48g", "user_id_md5": "54ade7cc5131a18490493a0cc4e460aa", "user_name": "@azx43", "user_name_md5": "ed73e9e7844dddaebf6ea57fe204817f" }, { "reply_text": " @kes1709  Purple on this chaty clearlt represents Germanic. It includes the Franks, Dutch, Germans (broadly) and even the Visegoths for example", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgxLW1x4dxq0dQBwtJt4AaABAg.9g2Mwnq1vB39g7XkhW0O5I", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC6Kkaj7aPNuZA2_btf55JAA", "user_id_md5": "23d2e1571b778be2bf12cf19288b745c", "user_name": "@sebe2255", "user_name_md5": "bf22f8e49691b23285e8cd434269b467" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCm4lBkeG_1-7D9xoHgpT48g", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxlR0V7xDbpHDPdR1F4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Second", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@exgamer3502", "username_md5": "88fd802f500f30d35ea1acc719448e50", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@exgamer3502", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Sorry, not second. :(", "reply_like": "1 like", "reply_id": "UgxlR0V7xDbpHDPdR1F4AaABAg.9g2DGjVy6AS9g2cMBTU9v3", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCqLekvlOZ_lTIZQDPPo4i-g", "user_id_md5": "ca48c236f444167a098083fca6b88365", "user_name": "@Hermes_Agoraeus", "user_name_md5": "de711ce21ea3174dd67f15e42518cf33" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC33-C69NhQjJYJ1H1M7TBoA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwqdwYjHWZRVB_mpbx4AaABAg", "comment_text": "I’m less than five minutes into this video and I find myself wondering why you titled modern day Spain and Portugal Hispania instead of Iberia? It was known as Iberia until it fell completely to Rome around 200 BCE. I could be off a century or so but feel free to correct me. I also noticed that you conveniently left out that there were other tribes/colonies such as Celts, Basques, Celtiberians besides the Iberians prior to the arrival of the Phoenicians. Also if you’re starting in the year 800 BCE you should’ve included the city of Cadiz in southern Spain. The Phoenicians were able to settle and establish settlements because they got along with the tribes that were there before which brings me back to the point of why would you leave out very important tribes/colonies out of Iberia/Hispania? I try real hard to watch your videos but I can’t finish watching any of them because of your disregard, disrespect and dishonesty of certain places in Europe. I keep hoping that the content you keep putting out will eventually get better but it doesn’t. On a positive note, your marketing skills are great. \n\nYou’re a very smart guy. Do better.", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@marcom6089", "username_md5": "c50396b24ba08326f6075e94b38ef294", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@marcom6089", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Also, Portugal apparently vanished in the 16th century never to be heard from again... lol", "reply_like": "0 likes", "reply_id": "UgwqdwYjHWZRVB_mpbx4AaABAg.9g6MCmYPEDp9hAVXm0BWDs", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UCtgeQ48eryJqW15K19plbDQ", "user_id_md5": "dfcf6d7c54a4962eba3bcdd2fa5b3bbf", "user_name": "@joaomramalho1", "user_name_md5": "cf4aa927615e1141cfa4c6385a60f730" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCHu4LbzWFVvVgPGe-F7ekeA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugx9yzbA1aCq3k8YGBF4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Your Kyivan Rus' branch is wrong. After Kyivan Rus' fragmentation in 12 century the Kingdom of Ruthenia existed in the lands of modern Western Ukraine and is considered a proto-Ukrainian state. At the other hand Muscovy was a descendant of a small part of the Golden Horde that wanted to conquer Kyiv but wasn't able do it at the time. So their prince Ivan III self-proclaimed himself a \" Sovereign of all Rus' \" only in 1493 (300+ years after the fragmentation) even though the lands of the former Kyivan Rus' were a part of Grand Duchy of Lithuania at that time.\nSo there is no direct connection between Kyivan Rus' and Muscovy, only delusional territorial claims of a bordering nation. Kyiv came under Moscow's rule only in 1686 after the Treaty of Perpetual Peace between Polish–Lithuanian Commonwealth and Muscovy.\nAnd such charts as this one aren't helping to debunk the centuries of lies of Moscow and the theft of Ukrainian history to justify the aggression. You are only helping the aggressor in the information war by repeating their historic propaganda. Shame on you!", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@large_hadron_collider", "username_md5": "a38e4f1168ff0d86f9d8e2ed7de4c74c", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@large_hadron_collider", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC5SGK53LWqryjc5lI6aREFQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugykje4yqu9UJWyKpNB4AaABAg", "comment_text": "@usefulcharts do you still offer the book for purchase? when I click on the link I get an error message \"404 Page Not Found The page you requested does not exist\"", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@thehuberts", "username_md5": "a3bcad3d154a6c088c2accabadd1528a", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@thehuberts", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCjwYP1eKmhwmRgvkvBV2GiA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "Ugz-irEmacNIZyhDsjF4AaABAg", "comment_text": "12:19: \"Norweigan\" is a typo. The correct spelling is Norwegian.", "likes": "1 like", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@ropersonline", "username_md5": "d08128534181eb0a18f616db8bece009", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@ropersonline", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCnRmENfkBo-Io_lWSh0ivPQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgwsmI5e4aBwo-fN4bN4AaABAg", "comment_text": "Reddit", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@RickJohnyALL-PROProcue", "username_md5": "21128c04b23d7d18f7954a670d932b42", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@RickJohnyALL-PROProcue", "date": "1 year ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCoJml5SbdA80dtWOw_pW4RQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgxFjn__fqjfyLF9W8x4AaABAg", "comment_text": "14:08: It's probably a mistake to omit Austria's Anschluss (q.v. @Wikipedia), which while undone upon the defeat of Nazi Germany, wasn't all that fleeting but of significant political consequence – and of course Hitler was actually Austrian (first).", "likes": "0 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@ropersonline", "username_md5": "d08128534181eb0a18f616db8bece009", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@ropersonline", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCnRmENfkBo-Io_lWSh0ivPQ", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyW0P68F6CLcL2IhKx4AaABAg", "comment_text": "First", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "1 reply", "username": "@rschmidtzalles", "username_md5": "742424a8bf347c772502e4f673e04f18", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@rschmidtzalles", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [ { "reply_text": "Not first", "reply_like": "2 likes", "reply_id": "UgyW0P68F6CLcL2IhKx4AaABAg.9g2D55S-MCL9g2DJwDB-dj", "reply_rank": 1, "user_id": "UC33-C69NhQjJYJ1H1M7TBoA", "user_id_md5": "307ae752e35ac0eab4f7ea7346ef8633", "user_name": "@exgamer3502", "user_name_md5": "88fd802f500f30d35ea1acc719448e50" } ], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UCYIqEbkQWoFm1ezVQbOySyA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" }, { "comment_id": "UgyW0P68F6CLcL2IhKx4AaABAg.9g2D55S-MCL9g2DJwDB-dj", "comment_text": "Not first", "likes": "2 likes", "replies": "0 replies", "username": "@exgamer3502", "username_md5": "88fd802f500f30d35ea1acc719448e50", "user_channel": "https://www.youtube.com/@exgamer3502", "date": "3 years ago", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_SdpvpvVrLY", "video_id": "_SdpvpvVrLY", "replies_value": [], "replies_without_names": [], "user_id": "UC33-C69NhQjJYJ1H1M7TBoA", "authorIsChannelOwner": false, "hasCreatorHeart": true, "title": "Timeline of European History Foldout Chart" } ]